Blog > How to Choose a Mattress – The Complete Guide 2024

How to Choose a Mattress – The Complete Guide 2024

How to Choose a Mattress – The Complete Guide 2024

How To Choose A New Mattress

Choosing a new mattress is not an easy job, I admit. But, knowing what you are looking for helps a lot in taking the right choice. Given all the manufacturers, mattress materials, and constructions; ‘feeling lost’ is a bit of an understatement. Yet, buying the best mattress is crucial too.

There is no ‘single’ mattress, perfect for all. But, you can make an educated decision if you know how to pick the best mattress for you. The specs you consider, depend on your age, weight, size, and sleep preferences.

How to choose a mattress

Sleep is an essential part of our lives. In fact, Americans sleep 6.8 hours per night. So, roughly you spend about one-third of your life sleeping! A quality sleep boosts your creativity and makes your day more productive.

Consequently, choosing the right mattress is essential for a peaceful rest, pain-free body, and stress-free life. To be honest, a comfy de-stressing sleep is a right, rather than a privilege, of every human being!

So, let’s discuss top 15 most important factors you must consider before investing in the mattress of your dreams!

1. Setting Your Budget

Half the people I know plunge into the mattress-purchase without even setting a budget. And it makes the mattress-hunt too complicated. It is crucial to set a budget before you start exploring your mattress options. Otherwise, you might fall in love with a mattress, only to get your heartbroken by the price tag later.

By the way, the relation between the cost and quality is conditional. Not every $5000 mattress is worth every dollar spent! With the rise of online mattress companies like Casper, Leesa, and Purple, you have a variety of cheap mattresses to explore


Our Pick: Casper

Setting your budget between $500 – $ 1000 is an excellent choice as it gives you a right mix of features.

For instance, with a similar feel and features, an in-store or luxury brand may cost over $3000 as compared to circa $1000 for its online counterparts.


Our Pick: Tempur-Pedic

For some luxury choices, you may raise your budget a little. The prices escalate with additional features such as the size, materials, and the layers of the mattress.
This price range above $1000 will give you a variety of options to explore.

But be careful – skimping below $500 will neither bring you comfort nor durability. Most $1000 mattresses last for around a decade, at the least! A comfortable bed is an investment for a healthy life. Thus, choose wisely!


2. Choosing The Perfect Material

Usually, the mattress models in the market are categorized according to their material. It is necessary that you consider your priorities while choosing perfect bedding based on materials. Let’s discuss some of their differences.


Choosing a mattress

Memory Foam Mattress

This molding foam hugs your curves and offers pinpoint support for all body shapes, preventing aches and pains in the morning. The gel-infused memory foam offers a good bounce and refreshing sleep.  The gel also absorbs movements well, providing undisturbed sleep.

Our Pick: Nectar

Latex Mattress

The latex is desirable for its comfort, longevity, breathability, and bounce. Latex mattresses have both natural and synthetic varieties, so it is better to do some research beforehand. Natural latex offers balanced comfort and support. It is healthy and eco-friendly with less off-gassing; ideal if you are concerned about allergies and asthma.

Our Pick: Zenhaven

Innerspring Mattress

The innerspring mattress offers strength, excellent bounce, comfort, support, and a cool sleep. Anyone with love for bouncy sleep surface can consider a traditional innerspring bed. Pocketed coils aim to provide a balanced sensation of comfort, support, and pressure relief.

Our Pick: Saatva

Air Mattress

Air mattresses are unique due to their strategically placed air tubes. The comfort level of such mattresses is adjustable. Studies support the air mattresses’ provide enhanced pain relief for quality sleep.

Our Pick: Sleep Number


If you prefer a water-based bed, this might be a viable choice. It has terrific orthopedic relief, especially suitable for people with arthritis. Waterbeds can also help with sleep apnea and prevent snoring. Many people consider waterbeds while choosing a crib mattress due to its impeccable hygienic construction. They may get excessively cold, but you can get a balanced temperature by using mattress heating pads.

Our Pick: Boyd Flotation


3. Variety Of Mattress Constructions

How to pick a mattress

Hybrid Construction

When browsing through various options, you’ll find a myriad of mattress constructions. Some are standard three-layered while others may be more or less. While some brands focus on additional comfort, others pay attention to overall support.

All in all, it may get a tad confusing unless you know what you are looking for.

Combined Foam Mattress

This model offers a blended mattress feel. Combined foams often have gel foams, comfort layers, and support foams. These layers enhance the temperature regulation and pressure relief of the sleep surfaces.

Our Pick: Leesa


This is yet another popular mattress construction. Hybrid mattresses contain a layer of spring for deep compression support, topped with latex, memory, or gel foam. The unique blend of layers ensures a pressure-relieving rest with a whole lot of benefits.

Our Pick: Beautyrest Hybrid Collection

Pillow Top

The Pillow-Top (and its variant; the Euro top) has an extra layer of soft material sewn or stuffed into the cover. While you may require a particular firmness and support, the Pillow-top offers you a cloud-like softness regardless.

Our Pick: Serta Pillow Top Collection


4. Prioritizing Sleeping Positions

Choosing a mattress without considering your sleeping position results in restless sleep, numb arms and legs, and neck, shoulder, back or hip pain.

Choose a mattress

Side Sleeping

Despite the health benefits, side sleepers often find difficulty getting proper spinal alignment and pressure relief. Your hips and shoulders may sink in too deep in a plush mattress while firm models may induce pressure points.

But you can never go wrong with a medium or medium-soft comfort level, especially if they offer deep compression support!

Back Sleeping

If you are prone to back problems, you should opt for a mattress that keeps your back aligned. The molding ability of memory foam and pocketed coils is desirable to support the spinal curve.

A medium-firm mattress works wonders for extra back support and relieves lower back pain.

Front Sleeping

Stomach sleepers often suffer from lower back pain and neck issues as keeping the spine aligned properly is a challenge. A soft mattress causes improper posture and aggravates this condition. You may even start experiencing inflammatory joints or misalignment.

If you get a mattress toward a firmer comfort level, it won’t disappoint you.


5. Significance Of Your Body Structure

Comfort is subjective, but the support or sinkage you feel on a mattress largely depends on your body weight. You should consider the firmness level, the material, the bounce, the thickness, and the temperature regulating properties suitable for your weight.

How to choose a new mattress

  • Lightweight (less than 150 pounds): Being lightweight, you don’t need to worry about sinkage. Therefore, try to go for a softer mattress to avoid pressure point formation. Cocoon by Sealy offers both soft and firm models. If you prefer a hard surface, a firm mattress is excellent for body alignment. An additional soft Pillow top further prevents aches and pain.
  • Average (150 – 200 pounds): Being average weight, you lie in the industry standard range. Luckily, most mattresses will be just perfect for your body! The choice of a good mattress comes down to the firmness and freedom of movement you desire. However, do consider your sleeping position before a final selection. Nest Bedding has some excellent choices for affordable mattresses made of natural materials.
  • Heavyweight (more than 200 pounds): Thick mattresses that are 12 inches or higher have remarkable support, resilience, and durability. Thus, these beds are ideal for heavier sleepers as they can enjoy the freedom of movement without feeling stuck. If you prefer a plush sleep surface, look for a mattress with deep compression support. Many people find sleeping on the Purple Hybrid mattress enjoyable due to its enhanced support and additional temperature regulating mechanism preventing the sweaty, uncomfortable nights.


6. A Plethora Of Mattress Sizes

The right mattress size has two significant benefits for you. First, the mattress needs to be big enough for your comfort. Secondly, consider the space you have in your room. Some standard sizes available in the mattress market are:

Many companies offer size variations ranging from crib size to Full XL, Short Queen, Split King, Split Cal King, and Split Queen.


7. Motion Isolation Properties

Motion isolation is a big concern for partners, parents, and pet owners. Light sleepers wake up due to minor disturbances such as a partner turning in bed. And it is too annoying! We all deserve an uninterrupted rest after a long tiring day.

How to choose a good mattress

So, to make your sleep enjoyable and peaceful, look for mattresses that absorb vibrations well. Consider these sleep surfaces, having excellent motion isolation properties:

  • Memory foam or hybrids with gel-infused layers
  • Pocketed coils construction in innerspring
  • Latex foam
  • Air mattresses with separate tubes
  • Semi-waveless and waveless waterbeds

Reading the reviews of different mattresses can help you understand the difference in motion isolation among various models.


8. Considering The Temperature Regulation Mechanism

Some people tend to sleep hot naturally, but some materials also retain body heat more. If you are aged above 40 years, you can relate to this issue. Especially, if you live in a hot environment, you should consider temperature regulation while buying a mattress. Most mattress makers are now using innovative technologies to bring you the most refreshing, cool sleep possible.

It’s well-known that the foam mattresses are the hottest. Thus, mattress makers use gel and phase change technology for cooling the sleep surface at night. Other cooling substances like metals and charcoal are wonderful moisture wicking agents.

Choosing a new mattress

Some mattress materials have intrinsic cooling properties. Latex has an open-cell structure that promotes heat conduction and convection due to enhanced airflow. The innerspring has empty spaces, also aiding ventilation and reducing heat retention. Water mattresses are too cold for comfort, so most people use heating pads with them.

In the end, it all depends on your personal preferences – how cool or warm do you want your sleep surface to be at night? Product reviews can certainly help you make an excellent choice for a cooling mattress.


9. Importance Of The Support System

A proper support system is necessary for a high-performance sleep. Your mattress should provide perfect back support. The best bed for back pain should provide proper spinal alignment. Sadly, many mattresses fail to do so which, at times, can result in chronic back pain or trigger old injuries. Ouch! Posture maintenance supports your respiratory system, prevents snoring, and improves your blood circulation as well.

While choosing a new mattress, people often confuse support with firmness. It’s not necessary that a hard mattress is excellent at offering lumbar support. Depending on your weightbody types and your overall health, a soft or firm support foam may be more suited to your needs.

How to pick the best mattress

Memory foam, spring, latex, air and water mattresses are all aimed at providing your back remarkable support overall. But again, your structure may call for a foam surface for proper cradling of hip and back, if you have prominent curves. For a person who is skinny, any surface may perform well.

Therefore, do your research accordingly so you can avoid any future regrets. Start by considering your weight and other related factors before you zero in on the final options. The Amerisleep offers support foam in many firmness choices whereas the Beautyrest Innerspring collection has extra features for back support.


10. Relevance Of Freedom Of Movement

If bounce and freedom of movement are essential to you, this is a relevant factor you should consider before buying a new mattress. Freedom of movement mainly refers to the ability to move freely across the sleep surface, without feeling stuck in it.

Bouncy or springy surfaces are perfect for you if you enjoy sleeping on the mattress, rather than in it. Many people don’t like the sink-in feel, keeping them from changing positions frequently at night.

Pick the best mattress

For example, latex, waterbeds, and innerspring mattresses offer such characteristics in their design – the springiness doesn’t keep you from changing your sleeping positions.

Memory foam has the least bounce and responsiveness. However, the addition of gel makes the mattress quite responsive and offers reasonable freedom of movement. You can also go for a hybrid to get the most of both foam and spring, depending on your requirements.


11. Choosing A Mattress With Edge Support

Edge support is crucial if you are a side sleeper or tend to move to the mattress edges while you are slumbering. If you share your bed with a partner or kids who take too much space, driving you to the brink, you need a secure edge to support you. If you roll off the mattress at night, this property will prevent such accidents.

How to choose the best mattress

Additionally, edge support is an excellent predictor of the longevity of the mattress. In the absence of edge support foam, mattress begins to sag sooner, making you feel insecure and uncomfortable lying in bed. Brooklyn Bedding, Tempur-pedic, Serta, and many more, use a high-density foam wrapped around the mattress core for extra edge support. Check out their reviews and mattress ratings from customers and product owners.


12. The Comfort Level Best For You

The comfort level or the firmness means how hard or soft a mattress feels to you. According to a poll conducted by National Sleep Foundation, 92% of people rank comfort necessary for a restful sleep. Firmness level decides how comfortable you feel on a mattress.

The comfort level is highly objective depending on your weight, build, and sleeping preference. The industry labels mattresses from Firm to Soft based on a person with average weight (180 pounds). The various firmness levels are:

  • Firm
  • Medium Firm
  • Medium
  • Medium Soft
  • Soft

‘Medium-firm’ is considered the universal comfort level suiting the varied preferences of the majority. Most mattresses use different materials and constructions to hit this sweet spot.

However, if you prefer a firmer or softer mattress, check out the collection at Brooklyn Bedding, Saatva, and Nest Bedding. These online retailers enjoy high mattress ratings. Still, not comfy enough? Go to Helix Sleep to get a personalized mattress, made-to-order for your preferred comfort, feel, and support. Read customer reviews to see how owners with different body types and sleep needs, rate the comfort of their models.


13. The Odor And Off-Gassing Issue

An average person sleeps equivalent to 26 years in his entire life. That is a lot of time lying on your mattress inhaling the chemicals used in mattress production. Off-gassing is the emission of chemicals from the mattress into our home environment. Every mattress gives off an odor, some more than the others.

How to pick a good mattress

Mattress materials pass various tests ensuring that they do not release any harmful gases. However, when you get the mattress out of its packaging, it is advisable to let the mattress air out in an open place for 24-48 hours.

If you have allergy concerns, you may choose a mattress with natural substances such as latex. Mattresses with wool or cotton covers and fillings minimize chances of any allergies whatsoever. The Nest Bedding, Naturepedic, and Zenhaven are great choices for mattresses made with natural materials.


14. Reputable Customer Care And Support

A brand that does not excel in customer care does not last long. How can they expect to survive in this raging competition if the consumers don’t feel respected enough?

Choosing a good mattress

Some brands like Casper, Tuft & Needle, and Leesa, have an excellent reputation for the assistance they provide. Their salespersons and customer care personnel meet buyers’ needs on a priority basis. They welcome users’ feedback to improve their product design continually.

Most online mattress companies also offer free home delivery and free returns/refunds to gain the trust of their customers. You need to consider three aspects while choosing a new mattress.


The industry standard warranty is 10-years. But each company has a different policy about what the warranty covers and what voids it. Some of the brands have a warranty for more than a year as well!


Free returns within a risk-free trial period guarantee you the peace of mind that you won’t be stuck with a wrong mattress. During the trial period, you get to experience the product first-hand in your home. If you find it right for you, well and good; otherwise, you can always quickly return it. But sometimes, you might have to pay a small surcharge!


Most mattress manufacturers offer a full refund on returns within the trial period. However, some may deduct the delivery charges of the returned mattresses while others may only provide an exchange and no refunds.

As for the returned products, rest assured! They are not dumped in landfills. Most companies collaborate with local charity organizations to donate these products to the needy.


15. Overall Mattress Durability

With an average Queen size mattress costing circa $1000, who wants to replace their mattress every few years! Durability is, therefore; an essential factor to consider.

How to pick a new mattress

Note the density and thickness of the mattress layers. They can be a strong predictor of the lifespan of a mattress. Latex is the most durable, guaranteeing sound sleep for years to come, but it’s the most expensive as well. Gel foam and memory foam are more durable than polyfoam. However, the Reflex foam is almost as durable as memory because it’s denser than a conventional polyfoam.

The coil gauge of the innerspring determines its durability. A softer innerspring mattress has a higher coil gauge, i.e., thinner springs are less durable. Thus, the lifespan of a hybrid mattress depends mainly on the density and thickness of the foam and the coil gauge of the innerspring used in it.


Well, this concludes our list of 15 important factors you must consider while choosing the right mattress for you. Happy mattress shopping… and don’t forget to share with us, the mattress you finally choose.

More Resources

Try & Buy Online-Only Mattresses in our Showrooms

  • Best Price Guarantee
  • Free Trials
  • Free Delivery
Try a Mattress In-Store Now!