Casper is a pioneer in the box mattress phenomenon. Sold online at Casper sleep shops, and in SleePare showrooms, they offer both hybrid mattresses and memory foam mattresses with delivery to customer homes. Their cooling memory foam has quickly gained popularity among its customers as "the coolest way to sleep".
While Casper mattresses do sell for as low as $500, some of their luxury models can go as high as $4,000. That might not be the best fit for struggling sleepers on a budget. Plus, some of the cons of this mattress brand may be a deal-breaker, depending on your preferences.
Never fear! We're here to help with a full list of Casper mattress alternatives. But first, let's review some of the best features of a Casper bed—and go over the ways that comparable models stack up.
Since Casper offers hybrid and foam mattresses, shoppers can choose a model that works best for their sleeper type, body type, and other preferences. Overall, Casper mattresses are very popular with side sleepers, hot sleepers, and people weighing in under 230 pounds. Their innovative designs offer maximum pressure relief while wicking away heat and moisture for a super comfortable sleep.
Here are the main pros and cons of a Casper mattress:
Pros:
Cons:
If some of Casper's best features really resonate with you, you'll be happy to know that many of their competitors have comparable models. We'll give you all the tea on the similarities and differences between Casper mattresses and their competitors—and give you a list of our top picks for what is comparable to a Casper mattress.
Many Casper-like mattresses, such as WinkBeds and Nectar, offer similar features such as cooling layers, motion isolation, and pressure relief. While the specific materials and designs may not be exactly the same, they can be comparable in terms of comfort and durability. Many of them also offer similar deals on sleep trials, shipping, and warranties so you can make the most of every dollar.
Several Casper-like brands offer more choices in size and firmness. Others use materials and features that are more compatible with certain sleeper types or even heavier sleepers. In addition, several of the brands on our lists offer more comprehensive sleep trials and warranties, such as Winkbeds and Nectar, which offer a lifetime warranty on their products and a longer sleep trial.
There are two main types of mattresses that are comparable to Casper: hybrid and all-foam models. There are also pocketed coil mattresses, which are similar to hybrid models in that they have a coil core, but they do not have memory foam. Because of this, they are the least comparable to Casper mattresses.
All-foam mattresses are made with multiple layers of polyurethane or latex foam. Here are some common features:
Pros:
Cons:
Hybrid mattresses have a layer of wrapped coils underneath a layer of poly foam. Here are their main features:
Pros:
Pocketed coil mattresses are based on the original mattress designs. Hybrid models are much more popular—and more comparable to Casper. However, some sleepers still find these models to be an ideal choice, depending on their sleep concerns.
Pros:
Cons:
If you're looking for Casper features but want to explore other brand options, we've got some great choices in this list. Here are the best Casper mattress alternatives:
WinkBed specializes in hybrid and memory foam mattresses at an affordable price. Their designs offer great support and pressure relief in multiple sizes from Twin to California King. You also get to choose your firmness from soft to firm.
Most Comparable Model: Casper Original
Price Range: $1,299 - $1,695
Pro/Con Comparison:
+ More firmness options than Casper (soft, medium, and firm)
+ Different size options than Casper (Twin to California King)
+ Better warranty than Casper (lifetime replacement)
+ Slightly better edge support than Casper
+ Firmer mattresses compatible with sleepers 250 lbs or higher
+ Firmer models work well for stomach sleepers
+ 120-night sleep trial
Pros:
Saatva prides itself on luxury quality mattresses without overinflated markups. Instead, they offer more affordable prices and amazing features that are definitely comparable to Casper. We're especially fond of the Saatva Classic. Be sure to check that one out!
Most Comparable Model: Casper Wave Hybrid
Price Range: $990 - $4,500
Pro/Con Comparison:
+ Better warranty than Casper (lifetime replacement)
+ 365-night sleep trial
+ More size options than Casper (Twin to Split California King)
+ More firmness options than Casper (soft, medium, and firm)
+ Better edge support than Casper
+ Firmer mattresses compatible with sleepers 250 lbs or higher
+ Firmer models work well for stomach sleepers
Pros:
Cons:
While they only offer hybrid mattresses, Helix is all about customization. With multiple sizing and firmness options, and a convenient mattress matching quiz right on their website, you'll be able to find the bed of your dreams in no time.
Most Comparable Model: Casper Nova Hybrid
Price Range: $930 - $1,800
Pro/Con Comparison:
+ 10-15 year warranty
+ Better edge support than Casper
+ Options for side and stomach sleepers
+ Specific models for plus size sleepers
+ More sizing options than Casper (Twin to California King)
+ More firmness options than Casper (soft, medium, and firm)
Pros:
Cons:
Tuft & Needle offers both all-foam and hybrid mattresses in addition to other household items such as bed linens and pet beds. Each bed is responsibly crafted with safer, more eco-friendly materials. Their beds have been hailed for being more affordable than their competitors with comparable features.
Most Comparable Model: Casper Element
Price Range: $630 - $2,500
Pro/Con Comparison:
+ More edge support options than Casper
+ Different size options than Casper (Twin to California King)
Pros:
Cons:
If you're not sure whether you want a soft memory foam or a supportive hybrid, Nectar makes the choice easy. Both their hybrid and all-foam models feature multiple cooling options and maximum pressure relief. Nectar memory foam mattresses are especially good for side sleepers.
Most Comparable Model: Casper Snow
Price Range: $399 - $1,138
Pro/Con Comparison:
+ Different size options than Casper (Twin - Split California King)
+ 365-night sleep trial
+ Lifetime warranty
Pros:
Cons:
Maybe. Casper mattresses are generally affordable and have great features. The best way to decide is to test out your Casper mattress before you buy it by visiting a SleePare showroom.
One of the best Casper-like mattresses for side sleepers is the Nectar. Each of their memory foam models offer excellent pressure relief so you can sleep comfortably all night long. WinkBeds is another great choice, since they offer a variety of firmness options for side and combination sleepers.
Casper mattresses can last up to 10 years. They can wear out as soon as 7 years after purchase. Properly caring for your mattress can help extend its lifespan.
Yes! You can try a Casper-like mattress at a SleePare showroom near you. Just walk in or make an appointment (recommended) and our experienced team will help you select the mattress of your dreams.
Yes. The Casper-like mattresses we have listed in this article are often recommended for people with chronic back pain. In fact, several of them have one "Best Mattress" awards for this exact purpose.
Next time you're looking for comparable mattresses to Casper, remember that SleePare has everything you need to get the bed of your dreams. Based on your sleeper type, your body type, firmness preferences, and budget, you can choose the ideal hybrid or all-foam mattress to give you the most comfortable night's sleep.
Emily StringerEmily Stringer is a Content Writer at SleePare. Emily has over five years of experience writing and conducting research for different industries. When she’s not writing, you can find Emily with her dogs in Lexington, Kentucky.
Don't hesitate to contact us. We're always happy to help.
Call 347.450.7788Dustin is the lead content creator at SleePare. With a degree in Computer Science and extensive experience reviewing mattresses, curating comparisons and advising on "best of" guides, he's truly a mattress technology expert.
Dustin has perfected this method by personally testing over 200 different mattresses, so he's not only able to discern the overall value of a specific bed, but to assign its value to different types of sleepers.
Along with creating honest and straightforward mattress features, Dustin enjoys creating pieces aimed at helping people get their best sleep ever.
When he's not creating helpful content, Dustin enjoys jogging, fishing, hunting and playing video games in and around his Virginia home.
Dustin Morgan