Compare> What mattress is comparable to a Stearns and Foster

What mattress is comparable to a Stearns and Foster

What mattress is comparable to a Stearns and Foster

What Is Stearns & Foster?

Stearns & Foster has been making high-quality mattresses since 1846. Beginning with traditional pocketed coil mattresses and eventually adding on some hybrid models, this brand has something for almost everyone. With each generation, they’ve adopted the newest and best innovations to make their products unparalleled in quality and performance. Each mattress is made-to-order for a truly customized experience.

The problem? Stearns & Foster mattresses can go as high as $7,000 for a luxury California King mattress. As great as their products are, that kind of pricing just isn’t in everyone’s budget. 

Mattress like stearns and foster

But why should shoppers miss out on such great features? Well, you don’t need to. There are plenty of mattresses comparable to Stearns & Foster that won’t break the bank. We’re going to give you all the details, coming right up. 

 

Stearns & Foster Mattress Review 

While Stearns & Foster doesn’t currently offer all-foam models, they balance this out with a variety of firmness options for different sleeper types, body types, and sleeper sizes. If you’re looking for more traditional style and functionality—and a heavy dose of luxury—this brand may be the perfect fit for you. 

Here are the main pros and cons of a Stearns & Foster mattress:

Advantages

Multiple firmness options

Innerspring layer offers natural airflow

Multiple mattress sizes from Twin to Split California King

Compatible with flat foundations and adjustable bed frames

Great support for back and stomach sleepers

Compatible with heavy sleepers

Excellent edge support

Eco-friendly cover

10-year limited warranty

Disadvantages

Paid shipping

May be too hard for side sleepers

90-night sleep trial is shorter than some competitors

Pressure relief only in hybrid models

Motion isolation only available in hybrid models

Hybrid or pocket coil models only

 

Maybe you’re looking for a little more pressure relief, as is found in all-foam mattresses. Or maybe you’re just looking to give your budget a little self-care. Whatever the case may be, we’re going to break down the similarities and differences between our best alternatives to Stearns & Foster mattresses.

What mattress compares to Stearns and Foster

 

Similarities Between Stearns & Foster and Other Mattresses

Many Stearns & Foster competitors, like WinkBeds and Helix, offer similar features—like cooling layers, pressure relief, and motion isolation. Since Stearns & Foster holds a patent on many aspects of their designs (including their coils) specific elements will not be exactly the same. However, we’ve found several models that are comparable in terms of comfort and durability. These brands also offer similar (or better) deals on shipping, warranties, and sleep trials to help turn shoppers into loyal customers. 

 

Differences Between Stearns & Foster and Other Mattresses

While Stearns & Foster has surely earned its household name, other brands offer more choices in terms of firmness. Others use materials and features that are more compatible with different sleeper types. Plus, several of the brands we’re mentioning here offer longer sleep trials and warranties. For example, WinkBeds offers a lifetime warranty on all of their products in addition to a longer sleep trial. 

 

What Mattress Is Like Stearns & Foster?

Despite their previous popularity, innerspring mattresses are not nearly as popular as hybrids have become. Brands like Winkbeds, Helix, and Tuft & Needle offer hybrid and all-foam mattresses to give customers the features they want—such as pressure relief, motion isolation, and cooling. They also offer a minimum 10-year warranty to help enhance customer trust and satisfaction. When searching for Stearns & Foster alternatives, make note of the features that mean the most to you so you can compare models and find the best fit. 

 

Best 5 Stearns & Foster Mattress Alternatives

Want luxury without the high cost? You might be surprised at what mattress compares to Stearns & Foster. Let’s look at a Stearns & Foster comparison to some of the top mattress companies in the industry.

Which mattress compares to Stearns & Foster

 

Stearns & Foster Vs. WinkBed Estate

WinkBed is an absolute pro at offering high-quality products at affordable prices. Their designs give sleepers excellent support and pressure relief from Twin to California King. Plus, shoppers can customize their firmness options from soft to firm.

Stearns and Foster Comparison

Before making a decision, it’s essential to weigh the pros and cons of the WinkBed Estate:

Advantages

Multiple firmness options

Multiple mattress sizes from Twin to Split California King

Multiple mattress sizes from Twin to Split California King

Compatible with flat foundations and adjustable bed frames

Eco-friendly cover

10-year limited warranty

Disadvantages

No pocket-coil models

Edge support not as good on all-foam models

Memory foam models may be too soft for back and stomach sleepers

Some models may not provide enough support for heavy sleepers


Price Range:
 $1,299 – $1,695

Stearns & Foster Vs. Saatva Lux Hybrid

If you’re looking for that extra dash of luxury, Saatva is your brand. They offer high-end products without the markups. Their amazing collection offers features that are definitely comparable to Stearns & Foster. 

Best Alternatives to a Stearns and Foster

However, like all products, the Saatva Lux Hybrid has its strengths and potential downsides to consider:

Advantages

Good temperature control

Compatible with flat foundations and adjustable bed frames

Multiple mattress sizes from Twin to Split California King

Multiple firmness options

Great support for back and stomach sleepers

Compatible with heavy sleepers

Disadvantages

Not as cooling as competitors

No pocket-coil models

Edge support not as good on all-foam models


Price Range:
 $990 – $4,500

Stearns & Foster Vs. Helix Estate

Cashing in on the popularity of the hybrid model, Helix sells hybrid-only mattresses with multiple sizing and firmness options. Specializing in customization, they also have a convenient mattress matching quiz on their website. 

Best Stearns and Foster mattress alternatives

When compared to Stearns & Foster, the Helix Estate offers a range of benefits and some limitations:

Advantages

Good temperature control

Multiple firmness options

Compatible with flat foundations and adjustable bed frames

Great support for back and stomach sleepers

Compatible with heavy sleepers

Excellent edge support

Disadvantages

100-night sleep trial is shorter than some competitors

No Split California King available

Standard ventilated cover (may not be eco-friendly)

Hybrid options only


Price Range:
 $930 – $1,800

Stearns & Foster Vs. Tuft & Needle Studio

In addition to other household items, such as bed linens and pet beds, Tuft & Needle offers all-foam and hybrid mattresses. Each bed is responsibly crafted with safer, more eco-friendly materials. Plus, their beds are often more affordable than others with comparable features.

Mattress comparable to stearns and foster

When evaluating Tuft & Needle Studio against Stearns & Foster, consider the following advantages and drawbacks:

Advantages

Good temperature control

Compatible with flat, foundation, and adjustable bed frames

Eco-friendly cover

10-year limited warranty

Disadvantages

Paid shipping

100-night sleep trial is shorter than some competitors

Not as compatible with heavy sleepers

May be too soft for stomach sleepers

No pocket coil models

Medium firmness only

No Split California King


Price Range:
 $630 – $2,50

Stearns & Foster Vs. Dreamcloud Reserve

With their 1-year sleep trial and a lifetime warranty, Dreamcloud’s customer policy kind of blows Stearns & Foster out of the water. This hybrid mattress brand is best-known for providing products that support people with back problems and chronic pain. They are also a great choice for heavier sleepers.

what mattress is like Stearns and Foster

When weighing Dreamcloud Reserve against Stearns & Foster, it’s useful to note the following strengths and potential areas for improvement:

Advantages

Multiple mattress sizes from Twin to Split California King

Compatible with flat foundations and adjustable bed frames

Great support for back and stomach sleepers

Compatible with heavy sleepers

Excellent edges support

Disadvantages

Medium firmness only

No pocket coil models

Standard ventilated cover (may not be eco-friendly)


Price Range:
 $500 – $3,500

Mattress similar to Stearns and Foster

 

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Stearns & Foster mattresses unique?

Stearns & Foster mattresses are made to order. Each model is supervised and crafted by a trained mattress designer. They even put their signature on the label when their work of art is done.

What hotel chain uses Stearns & Foster mattresses?

The Fairmont hotel chain has partnered with Stearns & Foster. They collaborated to craft proprietary designs used only in Fairmont hotels. Instead of the Stearns & Foster label, these mattresses are under the Fairmont brand.

Can I try out comparable mattresses before buying?

Yes! You can try a comparable mattress at a SleePare showroom near you. Just walk in or make an appointment (recommended) and our experienced team will help you choose the mattress that best suits your sleep position, preferences, budget, and more.

Are comparable mattresses to Stearns & Foster more affordable?

Sometimes. Brands like Winkbeds and Dreamcloud offer pretty economical prices for comparable features. Brands like Saatva and Helix are priced a little on the higher side. However, many of their options are still more affordable.

Conclusion

If you’re looking for luxury features at budget-friendly prices, there are plenty of brands that are comparable to Stearns & Foster. The brands we’ve featured in this article offer a variety of versions so you can customize your purchase based on your sleeper type, body type, and firmness preferences. Visit a SleePare retailer today to try before you buy, then get the mattress of your dreams shipped right to your door. 

Resources

Try & Buy Online-Only Mattresses in our Showrooms

  • Best Price Guarantee
  • Free Trials
  • Free Delivery
Try a Mattress In-Store Now!
 
Dustin Morgan

Dustin Morgan


Dustin is the lead content creator at SleePare. With a degree in Computer Science and extensive experience reviewing mattresses, curating comparisons and advising on "best of" guides, he's truly a mattress technology expert.

Dustin has perfected this method by personally testing over 200 different mattresses, so he's not only able to discern the overall value of a specific bed, but to assign its value to different types of sleepers.

Along with creating honest and straightforward mattress features, Dustin enjoys creating pieces aimed at helping people get their best sleep ever.

When he's not creating helpful content, Dustin enjoys jogging, fishing, hunting and playing video games in and around his Virginia home.