Best Place To Buy A Mattress In NYC 2023

What Are The Best Mattress Stores in NYC?

Searching for a perfect mattress in New York City can be challenging. The city is bustling with stores. Yet, in the city that never sleeps, quality rest is crucial. A lot depends on your mattress.

We’ve done some homework for you. You’ll get a handpicked guide to the best mattress retailers in New York City. Let this be your map to a perfect mattress that matches your needs and budget.

What Makes A Great Mattress Store

A great mattress store might mean something different to certain people. What is considered a “great mattress store” can vary based on what type of mattress you are looking for, your location, and your shopping criteria which we will explain more about below. Ultimately, at the end of your mattress shopping journey, the mattress you choose ends up being the most important factor; but you won’t get there unless you find a great mattress store.

This is significant since not all stores are the same, and different stores will not provide products of the same quality. When you shop at a great mattress store, you are guaranteed to purchase mattresses of the highest possible quality at a fair price.

Criteria For A Great Place To Buy A Mattress

When you’re looking for a great place to buy a mattress, here is the criteria you need to look for: 

Inventory Variety

When it comes to purchasing a mattress, it is in everyone’s best interest to have a variety of options available for purchase. When looking for a new mattress, you should shop at a store that gives you a variety of options to choose and allows you to evaluate mattresses based on their cost and how comfortable they are. A great mattress store should have a wide selection of mattresses available in a number of sizes and brands to choose from. They need to make it possible for customers to try out some of the most comfortable and supportive mattresses that the market has to offer.

 Even if having a wide selection of options is beneficial, it is equally essential to keep quality brands and items in stock. An excellent mattress store will provide a diverse selection of well-known brands.  Consumers who invest in luxury mattresses produced by well-established and well-respected manufacturers will enjoy a more restful sleep at night and feel refreshed the following day. Mattress brands that customers know and love should always be stocked at reputable retailers to keep customers returning.

Competitive Pricing

If you are looking at a specific brand across different stores, one of the most important qualities to look for is a store that offers reasonable and competitive pricing. Most mattress stores have a set price from the manufacturer but will often offer discounts during sales, holidays, and other special events.

A great mattress store will keep their pricing fair and competitive according to the Manufacturer Suggested Retail Price (MSRP). If you are at a mattress store that is selling a brand name mattress at a much higher price than a similar store or even what the manufacturer’s website lists, it’s in your best interest to look elsewhere. 

Offers fair returns, exchanges, and trials

In the age of online mattress shopping, most customers know that brands offer sleep trials, exchanges, and returns of their products. Some mattress brands will even let you sleep on a mattress for an entire year and then allow you to return or exchange it! A great mattress store will offer these policies and more. By offering these returns, exchanges, and trials to customers, the mattress store only enhances their credibility and promotes customer satisfaction. 

Where To Buy A Mattress In NYC

#1 SleePare Mattress Store & Showroom

Naturally, we like to think that SleePare is the best place to buy a mattress in NYC. However, where else can you find the best online mattresses, test them in person before buying them and get the best price? Not only does SleePare stock the best mattress brands, usually only available online, at our stores, you will also pay the lowest price possible for the same product you can find online.

SleePare specializes in training our employees to know the inventory inside and out. This allows them to go above and beyond when it comes to assisting customers. Our employees are not only knowledgeable about the mattresses in SleePare stores, they can also use that knowledge to assist customers in finding the perfect mattress based on their sleep position, body type, and more. 

As an added bonus, SleePare makes replacing your mattress in the Big Apple simple by offering free delivery alternatives and white glove delivery services.

Inventory variety

At SleePare, you’ll find a variety of the most popular and best-selling mattresses that are usually only available online. Customers can test out popular mattresses in person before purchasing. SleePare’s innovative model combines both in-store and online shopping for a unique shopping experience. SleePare only stocks the best! Our inventory includes only the best-quality mattresses and other bedding products from the best brands. When you visit the best place to buy a mattress in NYC, you can ensure the selection of inventory will be satisfactory. At our NYC store, you will find brands like Nectar, Puffy, WinkBeds, and more to both test out and buy. 

Competitive Pricing

Pricing is a major factor in determining where to buy a mattress. Luckily, SleePare offers exclusive discounts on our mattresses. When you visit our store, you can get a special coupon to use on the website of whatever mattress brand you choose. Additionally, we also offer certain models for purchase in store and all at a competitive and fair price. 

Offers fair returns, exchanges, and trials

Besides providing excellent customer service, knowledgeable employees, and a vast inventory, SleePare has a generous return, exchange, and trial policy on all mattresses sold in our NYC mattress store. SleePare offers a 100 night trial on any mattress! This generous policy also includes free returns and exchanges.

About The Store

Hours:

You may be interested in

• Best Mattress Stores in Los Angeles
• Best Mattress Stores in Boston
• Best Mattress Stores Miami

#2 Craig’s Beds

Craig’s Beds is a well-known and established NYC mattress store and is one of the best places to buy a mattress in NYC. The store is a family-owned and local establishment that has rightly earned its place as a top store in the city. Craig’s Beds currently rates at a high 4.6 on Google and has helped thousands of New Yorkers find their perfect mattress. 

Since this is a local company, Craig’s Beds wants to ensure their customers are treated like family. To do this, the store’s highly-trained staff knows their products and customers to help them find the right mattress. 

Inventory variety

At Craig’s Beds you’ll find a variety of mattresses that you can also test and purchase in store. The store also stocks art prints, adjustable beds, sheets, pillows, and more. Before heading to Craig’s Beds, be sure to check out their Comfort Match Tool. This quiz helps you find the best mattress for your sleeping position and body. When shopping for a mattress at Craig’s Beds, you’ll find an excellent selection from their inventory. The store stocks popular mattress brands like Summerfield, Beautyrest, Beautyrest Black, Serta and Serta iComfort.

Competitive pricing

This local mom and pop mattress shop knows that you could easily shop at one of the bigger national mattress stores. To keep customers coming back, Craig’s Beds offers fair and competitive prices on their brand-name mattresses. There, you’ll find mattresses starting at only $450.

Offers fair returns, exchanges, and trials

Craig’s Beds offers a 90 Day Comfort Guarantee on all their mattresses. Customers have 90 days from the day they acquired their mattress to arrange for a request for an exchange. The cost of exchange is 150.00. Every single returned mattress is either given away, sold to companies that recycle materials, or just thrown away.

About The Store

Hours:

#3 Casper

The popular online mattress company, Casper, offers in store shopping to customers in NYC. Casper, known for their memory foam bed-in-a-box mixes their online shopping model with more traditional in-store shopping by allowing customers to test out and buy their products in person.

Inventory variety

At Casper stores, you’ll find all the Casper products customers love online. This includes the original Casper mattress, pillows, bed frames, and more. If you love Casper products you’ve purchased online, you’ll also love shopping for them in person! At the Casper store in NYC, you can schedule a nap appointment to truly test out a mattress and see if it’s right for you. 

Competitive pricing

Casper offers their famous mattresses in store at the same prices as offered online. With both the Casper store and online store, customers can purchase Casper products however they choose at the same price.

Offers fair returns, exchanges, and trials

Like similar mattress stores, Casper also offers a generous return, exchange, and trial policy. Casper offers a 100 night trial on mattresses. Read more about Casper’s return policy here.

About The Store

Hours:

#4 The Clean Bedroom

The Clean Bedroom was one of the first organic and all-natural mattress stores in the country. For over a decade, the Clean Bedroom in NYC has offered the healthiest and most comfortable mattresses and bedding available. If you’re looking for an organic mattress, The Clean Bedroom is the best place for the eco-conscious consumer.

Inventory variety

At The Clean Bedroom, customers will find luxury organic mattress brands and bedding. Along with the highest quality organic mattresses, The Clean Bedroom also offers adjustable beds, bed frames, sheets, and home goods, all of which are made sustainably. The high-end products offered at The Clean Bedroom include a carefully curated variety of mattresses from brands like Vispring, Obasan, Naturepedic, Royal Pedic, and Savvy Rest. All mattresses at The Clean Bedroom are  free of chemicals and made from the finest all natural materials. 

Competitive pricing

As many consumers know, organic and all-natural products cost more. While customers expect to pay more for these products, they don’t want to overpay. The Clean Bedroom offers their products at competitive prices to suit a variety of budgets.

Offers fair returns, exchanges, and trials

The Clean Bedroom offers returns and exchanges on all their products,based on brand policy. Learn more about The Clean Bedroom’s return and exchange policy here.

About The Store

Hours:

#5 Keetsa

The brand, known for their environmentally friendly mattresses, has been providing quality goods since 2007. Like similar mattress manufacturers, Keetsa started as a local shop in San Francisco, grew to become a popular online mattress company, and now is one of the top mattress stores in NYC.

Inventory variety

At the Keetsa mattress store in NYC, customers will find the brand’s mattresses available to both test out and buy. Keetsa mattresses include a memory foam model and several hybrid models, all made with sustainable materials. At the store, you’ll also find sheets, pillows, bed frames, and more. 

Competitive pricing

Keetsa’s products are priced affordably to appeal to customers with varying disposable incomes. Compared to similar stores and brands, Keetsa offers eco-friendly bedding and mattresses at a fair price. For example, the Keetsa Cloud, the brand’s top-rated memory foam mattress, starts at $690.00. 

Offers fair returns, exchanges, and trials

Keetsa wants all their customers to be satisfied with their purchases which is why the store has a generous 90-day return policy. Read more about Keetsa’s return policy here.

About The Store

Hours:

Summary

With so many options available, it can be difficult to decide where to shop for a mattress. If you’re looking for the best place to buy a mattress in NYC, you can’t go wrong with any of the stores mentioned above. While you’re in the mattress buying process, SleePare can help. You can find mattress buying advice on our sleep blog.

Please Let Us Know What You Think

Please leave a comment below and tell us about your mattress shopping experience in NYC. We would really appreciate hearing from you. 

More Resources

• SleePare Mattress Store In NYC
• Cheap Mattress in NYC
• Mattress Disposal NYC