With sleep quality affecting pretty much every other aspect of your life, there are few choices that are as important as buying the right mattress. For over 12,000 satisfied sleepers, Puffy was their perfect choice. Offering memory foam and hybrid mattresses with great features, Puffy has quickly become one of the most popular online mattress brands.
Unfortunately, for one reason or another a Puffy mattress may not be the right fit for you. If that’s the case, we’ve got you covered. In this article, we’ll take a look at what mattress compares to Puffy and the pros and cons of each of our top 5 choices.
Since their launch, Puffy brand mattresses have received tons of awards, including “Best Mattress for Combination Sleepers” and “Best Mattress for Back Pain”. Puffy products offer layers of luxurious support for almost everyone. They offer a 101-night sleep trial. Fall in love or your money back. How’s that for comfortable?
Here are the main advantages and disadvantages of a Puffy mattress:
Soft to medium firmness
Choice of all-foam model or hybrid models with a transition layer
Advanced cooling technology for hot sleepers
Great motion isolation for couples
Supports sleepers up to 350 lbs
Excellent pressure relief for side and combination sleepers
Multiple choices on size from Twin to Split California King
Compatible with flat, foundation, and adjustable bed frames
Lifetime warranty
Free shipping to the contiguous U.S. and Canada
Medium to low edge support
May be too soft for stomach sleepers
101-night sleep trial is shorter than some competitors
No firm option
As you look at the above list, take note of which features are most important to you. We'll be comparing mattress brands that are comparable to Puffy in different ways so that you can be sure to find the model that works best for you.
While our sleep experts were putting together this list, we looked at several factors to determine comparable brands to Puffy, including:
All of these aspects make a difference in how your mattress feels to you, how well it supports you as you sleep, and how it fits into your budget.
Some Puffy-like brands offer more choices in size and firmness. Others have different materials and features that are more compatible with certain sleeper types. Several of the brands on our list offer more comprehensive sleep trials and warranties. No matter what your priorities are, there is something for everyone on this list.
WinkBed is an online mattress brand that specializes in hybrid and mattresses with memory foam comfort layers. Their beds offer excellent support and pressure relief. They’re also available in multiple sizes from Twin to California King. Choose your touch firmness (from soft to firm) and you’ll have the ideal mattress no matter what your sleep concern.
Cooling technology for hot sleepers
Supports sleepers up to 250 lbs
Options for stomach sleepers
Motion isolation for couples
Pressure relief for side sleepers
Great for people with back pain
Better edge support for combo sleepers
May be too soft for sleepers over 250 lbs
Saatva offers luxurious mattresses at reasonable prices. They don’t skip out on the best features to cut the price either. The Saatva Classic is one of our favorite models in terms of comparability and affordability.
Supports sleepers up to 250+ lbs
Options for stomach sleepers
Motion isolation for couples
Pressure relief for side sleepers
Not as cooling as competitors
May not offer enough support for people with back pain
Medium edges support
Unlike Puffy, Helix only offers hybrid mattresses. But don’t let that cool you off. Helix offers multiple sizing and firmness options to customize your purchase. You can even take their mattress matching quiz to get suggestions based on your sleeper type, size, and preferences.
Models specifically for plus size sleepers
Options for stomach sleepers
Motion isolation for couples
Pressure relief for side sleepers
Cooling technology for hot sleepers
No all-foam options
Medium edge support
Tuft & Needle products include all-foam and hybrid mattresses—other household items like linens and pet beds. Each mattress is responsibly crafted with safer, more eco-friendly materials. Many consider this brand to be more affordable than competitors with comparable features.
Motion isolation for couples
Pressure relief for side sleepers
Cooling technology for hot sleepers
Better edge support for combo sleepers
May be too soft for stomach sleepers
Only medium firmness
Not as compatible with heavy sleepers
Nectar is one of the most popular, budget-friendly options online. Plus, all of their models feature multiple cooling options and maximum pressure relief. Nectar memory foam mattresses are especially good for side sleepers.
Motion isolation for couples
Pressure relief for side sleepers
Cooling technology for hot sleepers
Custom temperature control options
May be too soft for stomach sleepers
Only medium firmness
Not as compatible with heavy sleepers
Medium edge support
If you're looking to explore other brand options comparable to Puffy, we've got some great options in this list. Here, we're doing a Puffy mattress comparison with some of our favorite brands.
While the Puffy Mattress is a popular option, you might want to explore the WinkBed Gravity Lux as an alternative. Consider the following pros and cons:
Free shipping to the contiguous U.S. and Canada
Available in soft, medium, and firm
Moderate back support
Good for all sleeper types
Sizes are limited, only ranging from Twin to California King
Only a 101-night sleep trial (compared to some brands that offer longer trials)
The Puffy Mattress is a popular choice, but you might want to look at the Saatva Loom & Leaf as another option. Think about the following pros and cons:
Sizes range from Twin to Split California King
Offers a generous 365-night sleep trial
Available in both medium and firm options
Free shipping to the contiguous U.S. and Canada
Moderate back support
Moderate cooling
Good for all sleeper types
While the Puffy Mattress is a popular option, you might want to look into the Tuft & Needle Mint as another choice. Think about the following pros and cons:
Moderate cooling
Medium firmness
Excellent pressure relief
Suitable for all sleeper types
Supports heavier sleepers
Excellent back support
Size options are limited from Twin to California King
Only a 10-year warranty, compared to some that offer lifetime warranties
100-night sleep trial might be shorter than some competitors
Shipping is not free; customers have to pay
While the Puffy Mattress is a popular option, you might want to explore the Nectar Memory Foam as an alternative. Consider the following pros and cons:
Lifetime warranty
Free shipping to the contiguous U.S. and Canada
365-night sleep trial
Compatible with flat, foundation, and adjustable bed frames
Moderate back support
Moderate cooling
Medium firmness
Excellent pressure relief
Good for all sleeper types
Supports heavier sleepers
Size options are limited, ranging from Twin to Split King
While the Puffy Lux Hybrid is a well-liked choice, you might want to consider the The Winkbed Hybrid as another option. Think about the following pros and cons:
Sizes Twin to Split Ca. King
Lifetime warranty
Soft, medium, and firm options
365-night sleep trial
Free shipping to the contiguous U.S. and Canada
Soft, lux.-firm, firm, and plus
Good for all sleeper types
Supports heavier sleepers
Sizes Twin to California King
101-night sleep trial
The Puffy Lux Hybrid is a well-known option, but you might want to explore the Saatva Classic as an alternative. Consider the following pros and cons:
Sizes Twin to Split Ca. King
Lifetime warranty
Soft, medium, and firm options
365-night sleep trial
Free shipping to the contiguous U.S. and Canada
Compatible with flat, foundation, and adjustable bed frames
Excellent back support
Moderate cooling
Excellent pressure relief
Good for all sleeper types
Supports heavier sleepers
Although the Puffy Lux Hybrid is a popular option, you might want to explore the Saatva Latex Hybrid as an alternative. Consider the following pros and cons:
Lifetime warranty
Free shipping to the contiguous U.S. and Canada
Compatible with flat, foundation, and adjustable bed frames
Medium firmness
Excellent pressure relief
Good for all sleeper types
Supports heavier sleepers
Sizes Twin to Ca. King
Moderate back support
Although the Puffy Lux Hybrid is a popular option, you might want to explore the Nectar Hybrid as an alternative. Take into account the following pros and cons:
Compatible with flat, foundation, and adjustable bed frames
Moderate back support
Moderate cooling
Excellent pressure relief
Good for all sleeper types
Supports heavier sleepers
Sizes Twin to Ca. King
10-15 year warranty
100-night sleep trial
Free shipping to the contiguous U.S.
While the Puffy Lux Hybrid is a favored choice, you might want to explore the Helix Luxe Collection as an alternative. Consider the following pros and cons:
Lifetime warranty
Free shipping to the contiguous U.S. and Canada
Compatible with flat, foundation, and adjustable bed frames
Moderate back support
Moderate cooling
Medium firmness
Excellent pressure relief
Good for all sleeper types
Supports heavier sleepers
Sizes Twin to Split King
While the Puffy Royal Hybrid is a sought-after choice, exploring the Helix Elite Collection as an alternative might be worth your time. Take into account the following pros and cons:
Compatible with flat, foundation, and adjustable bed frames
Excellent back support
Excellent cooling
Excellent pressure relief
Good for all sleeper types
Supports heavier sleepers
Sizes Twin to Ca. King
10-15 year warranty
100-night sleep trial
Free shipping to the contiguous U.S.
While the Puffy Royal Hybrid is a popular option, you might want to explore the Tuft & Needle Mint Hybrid as an alternative. Consider the following pros and cons:
Compatible with flat, foundation, and adjustable bed frames
Excellent cooling
Soft firmness
Excellent pressure relief
Good for all sleeper types
May be too soft for heavy sleepers
Sizes Twin to Ca. King
10-year warranty
Paid shipping
Moderate back support
While the Puffy Royal Hybrid is a well-liked choice, you might want to look into the Nectar Premier Copper Hybrid as an alternative. Think about the following pros and cons:
Lifetime warranty
Free shipping to the contiguous U.S. and Canada
Compatible with flat, foundation, and adjustable bed frames
Moderate back support
Excellent cooling
Excellent pressure relief
Good for all sleeper types
Supports heavier sleepers
Medium firmness
Sizes Twin to Split King
Mattresses similar to Puffy start at $599 for a Twin size. At the higher end, the starting price is around $1,439. The maximum price, depending on the size, can be up to $5,000. Discounts are offered periodically, depending on the brand.
Yes, they can be. Many brands comparable to Puffy are very highly rated and well-made. For example, Saatva brand mattresses are considered luxury durable.
Yes, some Puffy alternatives have trial periods and warranties that are similar to Puffy’s. Others are much longer. Some are slightly less.
The best way to know which Puffy alternative is right for you is to take note of the features of the Puffy mattress you like most. The best alternative will likely be the one most similar to that in terms of construction and benefits. In general, side and combination sleepers may be more comfortable on memory foam mattresses. Back and stomach sleepers often do better on hybrid mattresses or those with firmer support.
Next time you’re wondering what is comparable to a Puffy mattress, check out our blog. We’re constantly updating our lists to reflect the newest innovations. With our comprehensive lists of pros, cons, and features, you’ll be able to select a mattress based on your sleeper type, your body type, firmness preferences, and budget.
What did you think of our list? Have you recently had a mattress shopping experience you’d like to share? Leave your thoughts in our comments section!
Showrooms
Meet The Author:
Shanir Kol
Shanir Kol, founder and CEO of SleePare, pioneered the “Try and Buy” model in eCommerce, enhancing mattress shopping by combining in-store trials with online purchases. Launching in 1999, his company focuses on customer satisfaction and eco-friendly practices, aiming to minimize mattress waste and expand sustainably.