Top 10 Tempur-Pedic Mattress Alternatives [2023 Reviews]

Since 1992, Tempur-Pedic has been the to-go for top quality mattresses. Developed from NASA technology, Tempur-Pedic is known for features like cooling and the mattress giant’s signature memory foam. 

The company changed the mattress market forever with the body-conforming foam. Now, consumers have more options than ever when purchasing a new mattress. Those looking for a quality mattress no longer have to shell out thousands for a good night’s sleep. 

Tempur-Pedic is still a major player in the mattress industry. Many more competitors stepped up to the plate as worthy challengers. Here are 10 of the best Tempur-Pedic mattress alternatives. Read on to learn more about each mattress to decide which will work best for you. Best of all, you can test these alternatives at both Sleepare locations!

1. Puffy

2. Winkbeds Plus

3. Brooklyn Bedding Spartan

4. DreamCloud

5. Helix Elite

6. Brooklyn Bedding Aurora

7. Novosbed

8. Helix Midnight Luxe

9. Nectar

10. Saatva

1. Puffy

Best For: The Puffy mattress is perfect for hot sleepers who sweat frequently. The Climate Adaptive Regulation Foam helps prevent sweating and keeps you cool and comfortable while you sleep. While the cost is higher than some competitors on this list, Puffy’s thick and supportive base and cooling technology ensures that satisfied customers will keep this mattress for years to come.

Another direct to consumer mattress manufacturer, Puffy strives to be the “Internet’s most comfortable mattress.” 

This medium/firm mattress blends three foam layers for maximum comfort and pressure relief. Puffy is 10 inches of soft yet supportive material. The first layer is Puffy’s patented Cloud Cooling Foam. Designed to cool, contour, and ease painful joints, the Cloud Cooling Foam dissipates body heat to keep you refreshed and pain-free all night long. 

Underneath the Cloud Cooling Foam is the 2-inch layer of Climate Adaptive Regulation Foam. This layer helps with heat dissipation and distribution, which helps keep the mattress cool. The Climate Adaptive Regulation Foam absorbs moisture and humidity created by body heat, leaving you comfortable and dry. 

The last layer is a 6 inch thick Core Support Foam. This powerful support helps increase pressure relief and prolongs the life of the mattress. Puffy’s Core Support Foam is four times more supportive than similar beds on the market.

Puffy’s customer support offers an instant refund for customers unsatisfied with their purchase during the 100 night trial. The Puffy mattress fits on any foundational surface bed frame, making it an excellent choice for those who are considering moving multiple times or updating their bedroom suite.

2. WinkBeds Plus

Best For: The edge support is great for couples and those who sleep with children and pets. This mattress is recommended for heavier people who need extra support to prevent mattress sagging. Overall, anyone looking for a comfortable, quality mattress who doesn’t mind paying a higher price. 

WinkBed’s Plus is one of the top-rated mattresses at Sleepare for a good reason. One of the best innerspring mattresses on the market, WinkBed’s takes their company motto “sleep better, live better” seriously. 

The WinkBed Plus is a 14.5 inch innerspring mattress designed to support heavier weight ranges. The Euro-pillow top Body Impression-Proof foam layer helps prevent sagging- a common mattress issue. This hybrid mattress is made with a 7-Zoned 10% Support Latex layer that acts as a transition layer between the comfort top layers and the bottom support layer. 

The latex is both flexible and supportive, preventing sinkage all while staying soft and comfortable. The 7-Zoned Support latex helps with pressure relief so you can get a great night’s sleep while your body stays aligned so you wake up refreshed and pain free. The reinforced coils are bound together for durability. Foam rails along the mattress edge keep you secure and prevent kids from rolling out of the bed. 

Topped with a soft, Tencel cover, WinkBeds Plus is a comfy, crisp, and supportive mattress.

3. Brooklyn Bedding Spartan 

Best For: The Spartan is specially designed for athletes and those who live an active lifestyle. This mattress is best for those who are heavily invested in sports, fitness, or an active lifestyle, and who don’t mind spending more on a mattress.

Brooklyn Bedding’s Spartan Mattress is designed especially for athletes who need extra muscle recovery. The high-tech design helps every athlete from the neighborhood runner to the professionals get the deep sleep they need to promote recovery. 

Three firmness levels in soft, medium, and firm mean the Spartan caters to various sleeping positions and pressure relief options. The secure edges and subtle bounce on the top surface make this a safe and durable mattress. But, the main highlight of the Spartan is the FDA approved performance fabric. 

Exclusive to Brooklyn Bedding, the patented Nanobionic RE-3TM technology converts your body heat into energy waves that improve blood circulation. This increases oxygen levels and helps your muscles recover fast so you can get back in the gym. This is the same technology used in athletic wear. 

The Spartan is also topped with an antimicrobial CopperGel Energex keeps the mattress surface free from germs and pulls heat away from the body. This CopperGel works with the RE-3TM technology to draw body heat in to convert into energy waves. 

The Spartan is also outfitted with a viscoelastic memory foam that contours your body and offers additional support. Coupled with 8-inch Quantum Edge Pocketed coils that support and provide healthy spinal alignment. The Quantum Edge Pocketed Coils have gaps between them for additional airflow to help you stay cool. Underneath the memory foam and coils is a 1-inch of base foam that supports the entire mattress frame. 

One of the highest-rated mattresses for comfort, support, and pain relief at Sleepare, Brooklyn Bedding’s Spartan is perfectly designed for those who live an active lifestyle.

4. DreamCloud 

Best For: This high support mattress is best for side and back sleepers as the supportive foam is ideal for those pressure points. The DreamCloud is perfect for those with back pain and injuries who need the extra support and pain relief. 

Just as the name suggests, this mattress is like having a dream while sleeping on a cloud. The DreamCloud mattress implements memory foam and innerspring coils for maximum support and comfort. One of Sleepare’s top-rated mattresses, this luxury hybrid mattress is 15 inches thick and has six layers of the highest quality materials for comfortable sleep every night. 

The layers include DreamCloud’s signature Cashex Cashmere blend cover. The Cashex cover is made from Mongolian cashmere, which keeps you cool by wicking moisture. Underneath the soft and lightweight cover is three layers of memory foam designed to conform to your body while relieving pressure and minimizing motion transfer to keep you sleeping sound.

Underneath the three layers of memory foam is DreamCloud’s signature Edge-to-Edge individually Encased Coils. These coils, along with the memory foam, combine the best of traditional and new mattress technology for the ultimate snooze. The DreamCoud’s last layer is a base of porous foam to improve and increase airflow. This layer also helps with the natural vibrations of the coils. 

The DreamCloud isn’t too soft, or too firm. Designed to be “just right”, this mattress is both soft and supportive. Dreamcloud offers a 365-day return and a lifetime warranty. 

5. Helix Elite

Best For: Helix Sleep is renowned as a leading US-based mattress manufacturer for its commitment to quality and innovation. Their Elite collection has taken their craftsmanship to new heights, combining advanced materials and meticulous engineering to deliver a sleep surface that surpasses your wildest dreams.

So, if you’re ready to elevate your sleep to unparalleled heights, explore the world of Helix Elite mattress reviews. Discover if this luxurious sleep solution is the key to unlocking the rejuvenating rest you deserve and take the first step towards a lifetime of unparalleled comfort.

Helix Sleep offers six Helix Elite mattresses, each delivering exceptional comfort and support. With a range of firmness options, these mattresses cater to various sleep preferences. The Elite collection has advanced features, including zoned lumbar support and excellent motion isolation. Helix Elite mattresses provide targeted support and pressure relief whether you’re a back, stomach, or side sleeper. Upgrade your sleep with the Helix Elite collection and enjoy nights of unparalleled comfort.

Moreover, Helix offers a 100-night trial, ensuring ample time to experience the mattress in your home.

6. Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Hybrid

Best For: Brooklyn Bedding’s Aurora is best for hot sleepers such as those living in warm, humid climates and for sufferers of night sweats. While priced higher than other Tempur-Pedic alternatives, Brooklyn Bedding designs and makes their products with high-quality materials at a lower price than competitors.  

The Aurora Hybrid from Brooklyn Bedding is for those who don’t like it hot. Featuring exclusive Copper Gel Energex and Titan Cool foams, the Aurora uses advanced cooling technology. Copper Gel Energex draws heat away from the body while Titan Cool assists in all-night temperature regulation. These foams help improve air circulation among the coils. 

Brooklyn Bedding’s patented Viscoelastic Memory foam, similar to latex, provides superior movement response and adjusts to your sleeping position. This memory foam also provides motion isolation and pressure relief for restful and comfortable sleep. The Aurora’s coils prevent movements from disrupting sleep and move independently. Gaps between the coils ventilate the core of the mattress, cooling the surface further. 

Available in three comfort levels, soft, medium, and firm, the Aurora features three unique, functional foam layers, and a pocketed springs support core. Each Aurora contains the same foam layers providing customers with the same comfort features regardless of comfort level. 

Measuring 13.5 inches thick, this hybrid, cooling, and antimicrobial mattress is the complete package for those wanting excellent comfort and support. 

7. Novosbed

Best For: The Novosbed is great for those who want to make a long-term investment in a mattress and foresee needs to change firmness. Reviewers state that this mattress is perfect for side sleepers and those who sleep with kids, partners, or pets as the multi-layer foam has excellent motion transfer. The Novosbed’s excellent edge support also makes it perfect for those sleeping with children or pets. 

If you like to stay cool and want to keep your options open for mattress firmness, Novosbed is the mattress you’ve been looking for! This mattress-in-a-box has an 11 inch, three-layer construction that allows you to adjust the firmness with Novosbed’s free Comfort+ cover. The easy install Comfort+ goes over the mattress surface and increases the mattress thickness to 13 inches. 

Buying a mattress online can be tricky. Novosbed aims to fix this problem by allowing customers to choose the best mattress firmness and to go back to their desired firmness levels if their needs change. The Novosbed is essentially three mattresses in one! 

Even though the Comfort+ allows you to change the firmness, the Novosbed is available in soft, medium, and firm for customers who know the level they need. Each firmness level contains heat dissipation, open-cell airflow technology, transitional foam, and are CertiPUR-US® Certified. Novosbed designs each firmness level with different sleeping positions in mind. The manufacturer recommends soft and medium for side and back sleepers and firm for stomach sleepers. 

The experts at Novosbed created both their mattress and Comfort+ based on customer feedback. The Novosbed is one of the most popular mattresses at Sleepare. With a 15 year warranty and a 120 night trial period, Novosbed gives you plenty of time to find your comfort level. 

The mattress itself has a Tencel cover for maximum softness and moisture wicking. Paired with the high-density memory foam and AirFlow Gel foam, this mattress will keep you both comfortable and cool while you snooze. 

8. Helix Midnight Luxe 

Best For:  Helix’s Midnight Luxe hybrid mattress is one of the most comfortable and highest-rated mattresses available today, making it perfect for those who don’t mind spending more on quality. We recommend this mattress for side sleepers and those who want to keep their options open for firmness.

The second highest-rated and most popular mattress at Sleepare is there for a reason. The Helix Midnight Luxe, not only has an eye-catching name, it is one of the most comfortable mattresses on the market. 

Since Helix launched in 2015, the company has been providing top quality mattresses and excellent customer service, making it one of the best online mattress companies. Helix is one of the few mattress manufacturers with an online quiz that takes your results and provides the best mattress recommendations. 

Helix prides itself on providing the best solutions to common sleep problems and aims to solve those problems by creating a variety of mattresses that do just that. Helix designed the Midnight Luxe for side sleepers and provides zoned lumbar support to prevent pressure. Soft support keeps your shoulders pain-free while firm support keeps your hips and spine aligned to prevent pressure and pain. 

This 14-inch thick pillow-top mattress with multi-layer foam, including both memory foam and Gel Visco Form for cushioning work with the zoned coils that provide superior support and comfort.

9. Nectar 

Best For Nectar’s mattress is best for those who want a comfortable mattress made with quality materials, but without the hefty price tag. Allergy sufferers and those who like to sleep cool would also enjoy the Nectar mattress. 

Mattress is on the bouncier side than its competitors, which might not work for those who want a firm surface

The Nectar Mattress is affordable foam at its finest. With over 15 years of experience in the mattress industry, Nectar knows how to produce a quality product at a value price. Selling directly to consumers allows the brand to keep costs low, a major draw for those looking for a quality mattress at a value price. 

Nectar values customer satisfaction and input. Over the years as the company has grown, the design team at Nectar has taken customer reviews into consideration and designed products based directly on customer feedback. This has given the brand a reputation for excellence in customer service. The mattresses lifetime warranty and 365 night in-home trial period with money-back guarantee only makes purchasing a Nectar even more appealing. 

Known for keeping cool and durability, the Nectar mattress contains four expertly constructed layers of Gel Memory Foam enclosed in a soft, Tencel cover. The bedbug-resistant cover is ideal for those with sensitive skin that might have reactions to the ingredients in the memory foam. The refreshing Tencel cover is also resistant to allergens like dust mites. Limiting exposure to allergens can reduce symptoms and improve sleep and overall health. 

The 11 inch mattress is topped with Gel Memory foam for superb body contouring, and Adaptive Hi-Core Memory foam gives the Nectar it’s subtle, signature bounce for adding luxury and comfort. Within the Gel Memory foam layer lies Nectar’s Lush Foam that dissipates body heat and keeps the bed cool. The Lush Foam is one of the most advanced and premium gel foams available in mattresses today. Nectar’s signature Lush Foam gives this mattress its chilly trademark. 

Bounce and a touch of cold give Nectar mattresses targeted pressure relief for those who suffer from back pain and other ailments. The 6 inch base layer of the Nectar provides a sturdy base of foam which helps preserve the life of the mattress.

10. Saatva

Best For: Rated highly for support, temperature regulation, durability, and quality, the Saatva mattress is an excellent choice for those looking for a quality product. The Saatva is also ideal for side sleepers who need extra support. 

This sustainable and affordable mattress lives up to Saatva’s slogan of “Buy Smart, Sleep Better.” A luxurious product at a bottom-shelf price, the Saatva mattress is perfect for customers concerned with sustainability. New York Magazine named the Saatva the best all-round mattress of 2019. 

Available in both 11.5 and 14.5 inches, each model is made with three-layers including a lumbar support pad that keeps your spine aligned and reduces pain, individually wrapped coils with contouring properties and pressure relief, and a final layer of steel Bonnell coils that prevent sagging. Customers can choose between an organic cover or a Euro pillow top cover. 

• Firmness

The firmness of a mattress is one of the most important things to consider when replacing your current mattress. Firmness is subjective; what might work best for you, will be uncomfortable to your partner. Firmness levels are soft, medium, and firm.

Soft is recommended for people who experience aches and pains and need extra support on pressure points. Medium firmness will work for most, especially back sleepers. Firm mattresses are great for back issues, heavier people, and stomach sleepers. 

• Memory Foam 

Most mattresses today contain some memory foam, particularly Tempur-Pedic alternatives. Memory foam creates a “hugging” sensation that helps spinal alignment and molds to your body. If you are a hot sleeper, it’s best to go with a gel or copper-infused mattress to circulate air and keep you cool.

• Hybrid

Hybrid mattresses are growing in popularity. A hybrid mattress is made with multiple materials, including foams and coils. These mattresses provide both the support of coils and the hug-like comfort of memory foam. The coils in hybrid mattresses help prevent sagging and provide edge support. 

• Latex

Latex mattresses are one of the most expensive mattresses you can buy. These mattresses are still less expensive than a Tempur-Pedic. Latex mattresses are more durable than memory foam and hybrids. The material has more bounce than memory foam and provides more airflow. 

• Added Features 

Advances in mattresses technology allow for new materials, designs, and features for the modern mattress. Most Tempur-Pedic alternatives include either cooling gel, copper-infusion, antimicrobial materials, adjustable firmness, and more. These added features and materials are often the mattress selling point. 

Options are no longer limited when shopping for a top-quality mattress. Today, there are more options available than ever. From mattresses delivered to your door, those with additional cooling features, and eco-friendly designs, Tempur-Pedic alternatives are just as good, if not better than the original. 

If you’re in the market for a new mattress but aren’t sure where to start, Sleepare can help! Visit our website to find mattress comparisons, reviews, and more. Also, check out our blog for even more resources and information.