10 Best Stores to Buy Mattresses in Long Island

by SleePare - June, 2019
10 Best Stores to Buy Mattresses in Long Island

Statistic Brain reports that 43% of American adults still prefer to interact with the mattresses before buying one. As a result, online mattress brands’ showrooms are popping up across the country. Others are collaborating with local brick and mortar furniture or sleep products stores to provide their customers with an opportunity to test their merchandise before ordering them online or offline through the store.

Benefits of Offline Mattress Purchase

Despite the ease of mattress hunt online, a majority of people brave the pushy salesmen in stores to find the right mattress for themselves and their families. Mattress testing at showrooms and physical mattress stores has many advantages. Some of the reasons why customers prefer to buy mattresses from physical stores are:

  • A chance to interact with products firsthand.
  • Compare many sleep surfaces side-by-side.
  • Get opinions from sleep or industry experts.
  • Decreases risk of return/refund hassle.

Now that we understand why customers prefer brick and mortar stores over online mattress shopping, let’s look at some of the best places to buy mattresses in Long Island.

10 Best Mattress Stores in Long Island

Store NameAverage Customer Experience
(Excellent, Good, Bad)
Customer Satisfaction Rating
(Excellent, Good, Bad)
Delivery Process
(Excellent, Good, Bad)
Return /Refund Process
(Excellent, Good, Bad)
1-800FastbedExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
Find Store Near You
Raymour and FlaniganExcellentExcellentExcellentGood
Find Store Near You
NY Furniture DirectExcellentExcellentExcellentGood
Find Store Near You
SleepworksExcellentExcellentGoodExcellent
Find Store Near You
Cozy Living FurnitureExcellentExcellentGoodGood
Find Store Near You
Furniture Gallery of Long IslandGoodGoodGoodGood
Find Store Near You
Bob’s Discount FurnitureGoodGoodBadGood
Find Store Near You
Nassau Furniture and MattressGoodGoodBadBad
Find Store Near You
Macy’s Furniture GalleryGoodGoodBadGood
Find Store Near You
Mattress FirmGoodGoodGoodBad
Find Store Near You

1. 1-800Fastbed

Lady resting on a Beautyrest mattress,  available at best price in 1-800Fastbed
Largest Collection of Mattresses on Long Island

If you wish to quickly buy mattresses in Long Island, head over to the 1-800Fastbed store. It’s a 40-year old, family-owned mattress shop in Levittown. The company has a large variety of memory foam, latex, hybrid, and innerspring mattresses of different brands. You can find beds on display from brands like Serta, Simmons Beautyrest, Kingsdown, and other popular names.

If you seek futons in Long Island, 1-800Fastbed has an excellent selection including click clack sofa beds as well. You can buy futon covers separately as well. Bedroom furniture, adjustable bed frames, Boyd waterbeds — there’s a huge variety awaiting you at this mattress store in Long Island.

The customer service is great and the prices are comparable to factory-direct online mattress rates. Most likely, you’ll be dealing with the owner, Mark Graber, himself. Same day delivery is the highlight of the mattress buying experience at 1-800Fastbed. The customer satisfaction rating is extremely high and post-sale customer care is top-notch. Most beds are in stock, ready to deliver.

Pros:

A+ BBB rating.

A large variety of sleep products available for testing.

Excellent collection of Futons in Long Island.

Same day delivery.

Cons:

Only one store in Long Island.

Contact Brand

2. Raymour and Flanigan

Best mattresses on Long Island, Serta iSeries & Beautyrest in Raymour and Flanigan store
Eco-conscious Mattress Store

Raymour and Flanigan, established in 1990, is a family-owned furniture store with stores, outlets, and clearance centers across Long Island. The eco-friendly mattress store focuses not only on product and service quality but also its impact on the environment. The company owns private recycling facilities in its efforts to produce zero-waste.

Raymour and Flanigan sell well-known mattress brands like Serta, Sealy, and Tempurpedic, along with high-end furniture brands such as Cindy Crawford HOME, Natuzzi editions, Kathy Ireland home, and more! Clean stores and helpful salespersons elevate your shopping experience despite limited variety. For more variety, you can visit SleePare showroom in New York housing popular online mattresses for testing.

Raymour Flanigan Long Island stores are open 7 days a week. If you wish to get discount mattresses in Long Island, check out Raymour and Flanigan Outlet in Lake Grove to get up to 40% savings. You can also check out their clearance center in Massapequa for more discount on mattresses, bed bases, and other furniture items. However, do note that all sales at the clearance centers are final and warranties do not apply.

Pros:

A+ BBB rating.

7 mattress stores in Long Island.

Furniture for every room available including mattresses, bed frames and other sleep products.

Eco-conscious company .

Free consultation and virtual room planner.

Cons:

Delivery delays.

Only one clearance center and one outlet in Long Island.

Contact Brand

3. NY Furniture Direct

Cozy bed with a comfortable low-cost mattress from NY Furniture Direct
Best Discount Mattresses on Long Island

NY Furniture Direct is an awesome place to buy discount mattresses on Long Island. The prices are super affordable with models on display from Therapedic, Sierra Sleep, Primo, and Eclipse. The product and service quality is amazing with the best price mattresses on Long Island. Take your time to test the beds and discuss your expectations and budget requirements with the friendly sales staff.

The showroom has an awesome collection of beds, nightstands, dressers, and a separate section for kids’ furniture. You can also find discounted deals and huge savings on furniture for the whole house. The store is open 7 days a week and the staff is eager to go an extra mile to help you find the mattress of your dreams. Delivery is always on time and hassle-free.

Be sure to check out the Clearance section at NY Furniture Direct to save even more. Explore their collection online and then visit the store to check out the products. If you don’t find what you’re looking for in the store, find it in their catalogs and the sales associate with gladly order it for you.

Pros:

Affordable mattress collection.

Fun designs for kids furniture.

Friendly and helpful sales staff.

Timely delivery.

Cons:

Only one store on Long Island.

Contact Brand

4. Sleepworks

Storefront of Sleepworks, excellent place to buy futons on Long Island
Remarkable Selection of Futons

Sleepworks has been in business since 1983 and one of the oldest mattress stores in Long Island. The store at Massapequa sells high-end brands such as Beautyrest, Stearns & Foster, Serta, Tempurpedic, Aireloom, Vispring, Posh+Lavish and many more. The clean and cozy store has an extensive selection of handmade mattresses on display as well.

Sleepworks has a truly versatile collection of sleep products, mattresses, foundations, and other bedroom furniture. Whether you seek a murphy wall bed or futons in Long Island, Sleepworks greets you with excellent choices. The Sleepworks mattress store in Long Island is open 7 days a week.

Sleepworks is one of the best places to buy natural and organic mattresses in Long Island. The sales staff is pretty knowledgeable and assist you in the selection. They have some of the finest brands of organic mattresses in Long Island, such as Naturepedic, OrganicPedic, and Savvy Rest.

Pros:

B- BBB rating.

A large variety of sleep products available for testing.

Excellent collection of Futons in Long Island.

After-sale customer care.

Cons:

Only two stores in Long Island.

Delivery delays.

Contact Brand

5. Cozy Living Furniture

Storefront of Cozy Living Furniture store with stylish beds on display
Stylish Designs, Reasonable Price

Buy online or visit the stores in three main locations on Long Island. The clean and cozy place offers you an excellent space to test out beds and mattresses. Cozy Living Furniture is also known by the name of Long Island Discount Furniture. The prices are reasonable but you can still haggle your way to further stretch your budget.

The sales staff is polite and lets you explore the store on your own. If you ask for the best price or price match, you can get some of the best discounts on mattresses in Long Island at this store. Once you walk into this amazing store, you can explore one of the amazing selections of Futons available.

Customers love the designs and variety of mattresses, beds, and other bedroom furniture. You can find fun beds, bedding, daybeds, nightstands, and more for your children in the kids’ section of the store. The store is open 7 days a week. Delivery can take a few days and some customers complain of late delivery.

Pros:

A BBB rating.

3 stores in Long Island.

Selection for kids mattresses and beds.

Stylish furniture at an affordable price.

Cons:

Poor post-sale customer care.

Delivery delays.

Contact Brand

6. Furniture Gallery of Long Island

Cozy bed with a thick, comfortable mattress.
Outstanding Customer Service

This family-owned furniture store offers amazing discount mattresses from renowned brands like Serta, Tempurpedic, and Beautyrest. Located in Baltimore, the store delivers to the entire metro area. This clean and brightly lit furniture shop offers quality sleep products at an excellent price point.

Customer service is the forte of Furniture Gallery. Most often than not, you’ll be dealing directly with the owner. You can test mattresses and explore furniture collection for the bedroom and living room. Have fun furnishing your children’s room by selecting products from kids’ gallery.

Most customers report excellent experience shopping mattresses in Furniture Gallery. If you require custom-made mattresses in Long Island, you should stop by and consult the friendly and well-informed staff at this cozy mattress shop.

Pros:

Good quality sleep products.

Huge discounts on mattresses.

Personalized service .

Cons:

Only one store in Long Island.

Contact Brand

7. Bob’s Discount Furniture

Affordable and cheap furniture and bed in Bob’s Discount Furniture store
Low-cost Beds and Mattresses

Bob’s Furniture shops are good places to buy discount mattresses on Long Island. The furniture chain sells its own low-cost mattress brand, Bob-O-Pedic. Choose memory foam, innerspring, hybrid or latex mattresses to meet your sleep preferences. Prices differ for different mattress categories, height, and finish.

Walk in any of the Bob’s Discount Furniture Stores in Long Island and explore an exciting range of bedroom furniture, bed frames, and other bedroom furniture. The kids’ section has fun designs in beds, bedding, nightstands, dressers, and chests. Meet the friendly sales staff and discuss your budget and requirements to get the best deal.

Pros:

A+ BBB rating.

5+ stores in Long Island.

Variety of mattresses, sleep products, and furniture.

Low-cost mattresses.

Virtual room planner.

Cons:

Unresponsive sales staff.

Poor post-sale customer service.

Contact Brand

8. Nassau Furniture and Mattress

Storefront Nassau Furniture and Mattress store with beds in all price ranges
Beds in All Price Ranges

The family-owned furniture store offers excellent mattresses and sleep products from brands like Serta and Sealy. They have a clearance section right inside the shop where you can find beds and other furniture for an amazing price. Still couldn’t find what you’re looking for. Run through their catalog in store or online, and they’ll get it ordered for you.

Nassau Furniture shop can get you amazing discounts on mattresses in the long island. They do their best to match or beat the price if you ask them. Choose the items you want and get an amazing deal with delivery, assembly, and warranty all thrown in.

As with any other furniture shop, it’s best to do some research before going to the store. Knowing what you want is the best way to resist sales pressure. When you know what you want, the sales staff has a much better chance of finding matching products for you.

Pros:

A+ BBB rating.

Good selection of low-cost mattresses .

Multiple financing and payment options.

Virtual room planner.

Cons:

Delivery delays.

Short-lived products.

Warranty claim issues.

Contact Brand

9. Macy’s Furniture Gallery

Inside Macy's Furniture Gallery with Bear mattresses, best for active lifestyle
Top-notch Post-sale Customer Care

Established since 1858, Macy’s is a well-known Department Store Chain with outlets all across the US. The Smith Haven furniture and Mattress gallery are worth exploring for some excellent quality bedroom furniture, bedding and almost anything you need for your home or office. At Macy’s, you can test various well-known mattress brands such as Beautyrest, Stearns & Foster, Serta, and many other exclusive budget brands.

Recently, buyers report a less favorable customer experience, unfriendly and/or indifferent staff. The service quality differs from location to location. Macy’s outlet at Hicksville and Carle Place have the best reviews and highest customer satisfaction ratings. Moreover, the returns policy at Macy’s is quite customer friendly.

Pros:

A- BBB rating.

A wide variety of mattresses.

Good quality furniture.

Clean and spacious.

Cons:

Mismanaged store.

Poorly coordinated delivery.

Contact Brand

10. Mattress Firm

Aerial view of Mattress Firm with a variety of mattresses on Long Island
Various Brands Under One Roof

Like anywhere else in the US, there are a large number of Mattress Firm stores in Long Island. Sayville, Riverhead, Lake Groove, Waterleigh, and Huntington Mattress Firm stores are rated best for overall customer experience. With headquarters in Houston, TX, Mattress Firm is a household name for purchasing mattresses, bed frames, and foundations.

Whether you’re looking for high-end sleep products like Chattam & Wells or budget options like Hampton & Rhodes, Mattress Firm can be your one-stop shop. The prices are high but you can haggle your way to get deals or discounts and stretch your budget to the limits at Mattress Firm or Sleepy’s in Long Island.

The Mattress Firm stores have many brands like Serta, Simmons Beautyrest, Tulo, Dream Bed Lux, Sleepy’s, and most recently, the Purple mattresses. Purple is available for testing only in select outlets of Mattress Firm in Long Island. But, you can always try out Purple mattresses and pillow at SleePare in New York.

Pros:

Open 7 days a week.

Largest collection of brands.

Poor customer service at some locations.

Excellent deals and discounts.

Cons:

C+ BBB rating.

Delayed and uncoordinated delivery.

Poor customer service at some locations.

Warranty claim issues.

Contact Brand

All these stores are excellent places to get deals and discounts on mattresses on Long Island. However, if you happen to pass by Manhattan, be sure to visit SleePare showroom on Bowery Street to try out Leesa, Winkbed, Layla, and many other popular online mattresses under one roof.