10 Best Mattress Stores in Long Island

by SleePare -
10 Best Mattress Stores in Long Island

In the last few years, online mattress shopping has experienced an enormous surge in popularity. However, Statistic Brain reports that 68% of American adults still prefer to purchase a mattress from a brick-and-mortar store, as it affords the opportunity to try the product before purchasing it. As a result, showrooms dedicated exclusively to online-only mattress brands are popping up around the country, and other online brands are collaborating with local mattress and furniture stores to provide their customers with an opportunity to test their merchandise before ordering online or through the store. So where should you go if you live in the greater NYC area and are interested in testing out a mattress that is normally only found online? Here’s a roundup of the 10 best mattress stores in Long Island.

Benefits of Offline Mattress Purchase

Convenience is one of the many reasons that consumers turn to online mattress shopping, but is it really the best option when it comes to finding the best new mattress for you?. Testing a mattress in an actual showroom and has many advantages. Despite what some retailers may say, there is no one-size-fits-all when it comes to mattresses. In fact, what works well for one person may be completely wrong for another, making online reviews difficult to trust without the possibility to test out the product for yourself. Visiting a mattress store allows you to try out and compare a variety of brands all under one roof, and with the guidance of staff who can help you pick out the mattress that is right for your preferences, needs, and budget, thus avoiding the hassle of attempting to return a mattress that doesn’t work for you to an online retailer who may not take it back.

Let’s take a look at some of the best places to buy a mattress in Long Island.

10 Best Mattress Stores in Long Island

Store NameAverage Customer Experience
(Excellent, Good, Bad)
Customer Satisfaction Rating
(Excellent, Good, Bad)
Delivery Process
(Excellent, Good, Bad)
Return /Refund Process
(Excellent, Good, Bad)
1-800FastbedExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
Find Store Near You
Raymour and FlaniganExcellentExcellentExcellentGood
Find Store Near You
NY Furniture DirectExcellentExcellentExcellentGood
Find Store Near You
SleepworksExcellentExcellentGoodExcellent
Find Store Near You
Cozy Living FurnitureExcellentExcellentGoodGood
Find Store Near You
Furniture Gallery of Long IslandGoodGoodGoodGood
Find Store Near You
Bob’s Discount FurnitureGoodGoodBadGood
Find Store Near You
Nassau Furniture and MattressGoodGoodBadBad
Find Store Near You
Macy’s Furniture GalleryGoodGoodBadGood
Find Store Near You
Mattress FirmGoodGoodGoodBad
Find Store Near You

1. 1-800Fastbed

Lady resting on a Beautyrest mattress,  available at best price in 1-800Fastbed
Largest Collection of Mattresses on Long Island

If you’re on Long Island and need a new mattress quickly, head over to the 1-800Fastbed store, a family-owned mattress shop in Levittown. The company has a large variety of memory foam, latex, hybrid, and innerspring mattresses from a variety of different brands. You can find beds on display from brands like Serta, Simmons Beautyrest, Kingsdown, and other popular names. They also carry a large variety of futons and sofa bed.s

The customer service is great and the prices are comparable to factory-direct online mattress rates. Most likely, you’ll be dealing directly with the owner, Mark Graber, himself. Same day delivery is the highlight of the mattress buying experience at 1-800Fastbed. The customer satisfaction rating is extremely high and post-sale customer care is top-notch. Most beds are in stock, ready to deliver.

Pros:

A+ BBB rating.

A large variety of sleep products available for testing.

Excellent collection of Futons in Long Island.

Same day delivery.

Cons:

Only one store in Long Island.

Contact Brand

2. Raymour and Flanigan

Best mattresses on Long Island, Serta iSeries & Beautyrest in Raymour and Flanigan store
Eco-conscious Mattress Store

Raymour and Flanigan, established in 1990, is a family-owned furniture store with stores, outlets, and clearance centers across Long Island. The eco-friendly mattress store focuses not only on product and service quality but also its impact on the environment. The company owns private recycling facilities in its efforts to produce zero waste.

Raymour and Flanigan sell well-known mattress brands like Serta, Sealy, and Tempurpedic, along with high-end furniture brands such as Cindy Crawford HOME, Natuzzi editions, Kathy Ireland home, and more! Clean stores and helpful salespersons elevate your shopping experience despite limited variety. For more variety, you can visit SleePare showroom in New York to test more popular online mattresses.

Raymour Flanigan Long Island stores are open 7 days a week. If you wish to get discount mattresses in Long Island, check out Raymour and Flanigan Outlet in Lake Grove to get up to 40% savings. You can also check out their clearance center in Massapequa for more discount on mattresses, bed bases, and other furniture items. However, do note that all sales at the clearance centers are final and warranties do not apply.

Pros:

A+ BBB rating.

7 mattress stores in Long Island.

Furniture for every room available including mattresses, bed frames and other sleep products.

Environmentally-conscious business.

Free consultation and virtual room planner.

Cons:

Long waits for delivery.

Only one clearance center and one outlet in Long Island.

Contact Brand

3. NY Furniture Direct

Cozy bed with a comfortable low-cost mattress from NY Furniture Direct
Best Discount Mattresses on Long Island

NY Furniture Direct is another great place to buy discounted mattresses on Long Island. Prices are very affordable, including on models like Therapedic, Sierra Sleep, Primo, and Eclipse. Take your time to test out the wide variety of beds on display and discuss your needs and preferences with the friendly sales staff.

In addition to mattresses, NY Furniture Direct also has an extensive collection of beds, nightstands, and dressers, and an entirely separate section for kids’ furniture. The store is open 7 days a week and the staff is eager to go an extra mile to help you find the mattress of your dreams. Delivery is always on time and hassle-free.

Pros:

Affordable mattress collection.

Fun designs for kids furniture.

Friendly and helpful sales staff.

Timely delivery.

Cons:

Only one store on Long Island.

Contact Brand

4. Sleepworks

Storefront of Sleepworks, excellent place to buy futons on Long Island
Remarkable Selection of Futons

Sleepworks has been in business since 1983 and one of the oldest-operating mattress stores in Long Island. The store at Massapequa sells high-end brands such as Beautyrest, Stearns & Foster, Serta, Tempurpedic, Aireloom, Vispring, Posh+Lavish and many more. Sleepworks also has an extensive selection of handmade mattresses available for testing in their showroom.

Sleepworks has a truly versatile collection of sleep products, mattresses, foundations, and other bedroom furniture. Whether you seek a murphy wall bed or futons in Long Island, Sleepworks has access to just about whatever you need – including an impressive variety of organic mattresses. The Sleepworks mattress store in Long Island is open 7 days a week.

Pros:

B- BBB rating.

A large variety of sleep products available for testing.

Excellent collection of Futons in Long Island.

After-sale customer care.

Cons:

Only two stores in Long Island.

Long waits for delivery.

Contact Brand

5. Long Island Discount Furniture

Storefront of Cozy Living Furniture store with stylish beds on display
Stylish Designs, Reasonable Price

Long Island Discount Furniture is another great place to find discounted mattresses and bedroom furniture in Long Island. Prices are reasonable, but don’t be afraid to try and score an even better deal – ask the friendly sales staff for the best price or price match, you can get some of the best discounts on mattresses in Long Island at this store. Once you’re ready to purchase, you can do so in-store or the staff will help you place a mattress order online.

Customers of Long Island Discount Furniture love the designs and variety of mattresses, beds, and other bedroom furniture. You can find fun beds, bedding, daybeds, nightstands, and more for your children in the kids’ section of the store. The store is open 7 days a week. Delivery can take a few days and some customers complain of late delivery.

Pros:

A BBB rating.

3 stores in Long Island.

Selection for kids mattresses and beds.

Stylish furniture at an affordable price.

Cons:

Long waits for delivery.

Contact Brand

6. Furniture Gallery of Long Island

Cozy bed with a thick, comfortable mattress.
Outstanding Customer Service

This family-owned furniture store offers amazing discount mattresses from renowned brands like Serta, Tempurpedic, and Beautyrest. Located in Bellmore, the store delivers to the entire New York metro area, making it one of the most well-connected mattress stores in Long Island. This clean and brightly lit furniture shop offers quality sleep products at an excellent price point.

Customer service is the forte of Furniture Gallery. Most often than not, you’ll be dealing directly with the owner. You can test mattresses and explore furniture collection for the bedroom and living room. Have fun furnishing your children’s’ rooms by selecting products from kids’ gallery.

Most customers report excellent experience shopping mattresses in Furniture Gallery, particularly customers in Long Island who require custom-made mattresses. Long Island Furniture Gallery is open 7 days a week.

Pros:

Good quality sleep products.

Huge discounts on mattresses.

Personalized service and custom-made mattresses available.

Cons:

Only one store in Long Island.

Contact Brand

7. Bob’s Discount Furniture

Affordable and cheap furniture and bed in Bob’s Discount Furniture store
Low-cost Beds and Mattresses

Bob’s Furniture shops are ideal for anyone looking to buy discount mattresses on Long Island, but who aren’t concerned with brand names. The furniture chain sells its own low-cost mattress brand, Bob-O-Pedic. Choose memory foam, innerspring, hybrid or latex mattresses to meet your sleep preferences. Prices differ for different mattress categories, height, and finish.

Walk in any of the Bob’s Discount Furniture Stores in Long Island and explore an exciting range of bedroom furniture, bed frames, and other bedroom furniture. The kids’ section has fun designs in beds, bedding, nightstands, dressers, and chests. Meet the friendly sales staff and discuss your mattress budget requirements and comfort preferences to get the best deal.

Pros:

A+ BBB rating.

5+ stores in Long Island.

Variety of mattresses, sleep products, and furniture.

Low-cost mattresses.

Virtual room planner.

Cons:

Unresponsive sales staff.

Poor post-sale customer service.

Contact Brand

8. Nassau Furniture and Mattress

Storefront Nassau Furniture and Mattress store with beds in all price ranges
Beds in All Price Ranges

The family-owned furniture store offers excellent mattresses and sleep products from brands like Serta and Sealy. They have a clearance section right inside the shop where you can find beds and other furniture for great, low prices. If you can’t find what you’re looking for in-store, the sales staff can help you peruse the online catalogue and place an order for a new bed or other furniture.

Nassau Furniture and Mattress is another mattress store in Long Island that participates in price matching. Don’t hesitate to talk to the sales staff about the items you want and the price point you’re looking for; often, you’ll be able to get an amazing deal with delivery, assembly, and warranty all thrown in.

As with any other furniture shop, it’s best to do some research before visiting the store. When you know what you want, the sales staff has a much better chance of finding matching products for you.

Pros:

A+ BBB rating.

Good selection of low-cost mattresses .

Multiple financing and payment options.

Virtual room planner.

Cons:

Long waits for delivery.

Products may lack durability.

Contact Brand

9. Macy’s Furniture Gallery

Inside Macy's Furniture Gallery with Bear mattresses, best for active lifestyle
Top-notch Post-sale Customer Care

Established in 1858, Macy’s is one of America’s largest retailers with over 740 stores all across the country, including multiple mattress showroom locations in Long Island. Their mattress selection is expansive and includes all of the top brands, like Beautyrest, Sealy, and Tempur-Pedic. The sales staff at Macy’s can help you navigate not only the full selection of in-store offerings, but also the extensive online collection if the showroom lacks a particular model or size. You can pick up your mattress in-store for free or have it delivered to your doorstep. There is no delivery charge for mattresses $787 or above, but the “white glove” treatment – which includes placing the mattress in the desired location, vacuuming of the area, and removal of delivery materials – costs extra. Similarly, for an additional charge you can also purchase Macy’s mattress protection plan to protect your mattress against any damage, such as stains or tears.

If you’re not satisfied with your purchase, you can return or exchange your unused mattress by informing Macy’s within 120 days of purchase. You can initiate a return or exchange process by visiting any Macy’s store near you. Unfortunately, products purchased on macys.com cannot be returned in-store.

Pros:

A- BBB rating.

A wide variety of mattresses across multiple locations.

Good quality furniture.

Clean and spacious.

Cons:

Long waits for delivery.

Limited returns policy for products ordered online.

Contact Brand

10. Mattress Firm

Aerial view of Mattress Firm with a variety of mattresses on Long Island
Various Brands Under One Roof

Like anywhere else in the US, there are a large number of Mattress Firm stores in Long Island. Sayville, Riverhead, Lake Groove, Waterleigh, and Huntington Mattress Firm stores are rated best for overall customer experience among Mattress Firm’s Long Island locations. Though headquartered in Houston, TX, Mattress Firm has become a household name across the United States.

Mattress Firm stores have many brands like Serta, Simmons Beautyrest, Tulo, Dream Bed Lux, Sleepy’s, and most recently, the Purple mattresses. Purple is available for testing only in select outlets of Mattress Firm in Long Island, but you can always try out Purple mattresses and pillow at SleePare in New York.

All Mattress Firm mattresses come with a 120-night sleep trial that allows you to exchange your original mattress for another if it’s not the right fit.

Pros:

Open 7 days a week.

Largest collection of brands.

Excellent deals and discounts.

Cons:

C+ BBB rating.

Long waits for delivery.

Hit-or-miss customer service, depending on location.

Contact Brand

Visited all the top mattress stores in Long Island and still can’t find the online brands you’re looking for? Stop by the SleePare showroom in Manhattan to try out Leesa, Winkbed, Layla, and many other popular online mattresses under one roof.

Additional SleePare Resources