SleePare >> Mattress Reviews >> Mattress Comparison >> Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle

Nector Mattress

Nector Mattress

Tuft & Needle Mattress

Tuft & Needle Mattress

Top 10 Mattresses

95

1. Brooklyn Bedding...

  • 13" 5 layers foam and springs
Free shipping, in a box
95

2. Saatva

  • 11.5" 5 layers foam and springs
Free shipping, in a box
95

3. Brentwood Home...

  • 14" 4 layers foam and springs
Free shipping, in a box
95

4. Brooklyn Bedding...

  • 10" 3 layers foam
Free shipping, in a box
94

5. Sapira

  • 11" 5 layers foam and springs
Free shipping, in a box
94

6. Brentwood Home...

  • 13" 4 layers foam and springs
Free shipping, in a box
94

7. Nest Bedding...

  • 13" 5 layers foam and springs
Free shipping, in a box
94

8. Puffy Lux

  • 12.5" 3 layers foam
Free shipping, in a box
93

9. Leesa

  • 10" 3 layers foam
Free shipping, in a box
93

10. Winkbeds

  • 14.5" 2 layers foam and coil
Free shipping, in a box

Check out the Best mattress Coupons

Check out the Best mattress Coupons Coupons
Latest Mattress Reviews
91

The Leesa had one of the highest total scores among similar mattresses driven by its strong edge support, pressure relief, and responsiveness. Its top layer is made with Leesas proprietary Avena...

94

Saatva uses a technology called 'coil on coil.' Its memory foam layer is only 1'' above the pocket springs, which means that the mattress breathes easier, but it also means that you are not getting...

I love it! It's screams luxury, is perfect for an adjustable base, and will provide you with a great sleeping experience.

93

Puffy beds want you to feel like youre sleeping in the clouds and you sure do. It consists of two layers of foam that work to keep you cool through the night while offering excellent support for...

  • Brand Comparison
  • Trial Period
  • Warranty
  • Delivery/Shipping
  • Mattress Comparison Overview
  • Mattress Comparison Details
  • Materials and Construction
  • Firmness
  • Support
  • Temperature Regulation
  • Motion Transfer
  • Body Type Suitability
  • Sleep Positions Adjustability
  • Price and Overall Value
  • The Verdict - Which Is Better?

Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle Mattress Comparison

During the hunt for the perfect mattress, your gut may tell you to go for the most expensive mattress. But sometimes, even inexpensive beds offer exceptional comfort, support, and overall value for your money.

Nectar and Tuft and Needle are two such mattresses, providing a wide range of beneficial features for a low price point.

Without further ado, let's dive right into the Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle mattress comparison review to help you make a more informed decision.

Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle Which One Is The Right One For You?

Based on a plethora of customer reviews and a detailed features analysis, here's a summary to help you understand which is a better choice between Tuft and Needle and Nectar for you.

  • Nectar is suitable for you if:
  • You are seeking a firm comfort level foam mattress
  • You weigh more than 180 lbs
  • You wish to test the mattress in all four seasons
  • You are looking for a heat distributing bed
Learn More Learn More
  • Tuft and Needle is suitable for you if
  • You want a mattress that has a medium firm feel
  • You plan on moving or changing house soon
  • You are on a tight budget
  • You have joints pain and need a comfy and cozy mattress
Learn More Learn More
Customer Reviews
Comfortable Rating
Based on 12 reviews
88
Based on 488 reviews
92
Temperature Regulation
Based on 3 reviews
85
Based on 610 reviews
95
Most Positive Reviews
" I'm sleeping better now, and my joints, back and head feel much better for it!"
"I have an immune disease that makes my joints hurt all night. With Tuft and Needle, my joints are fine. I slept. It is good. "
Expert Reviews
Value For Money
Based on 9 reviews
85
Based on 11 reviews
78
Owner Satisfaction
Based on 1 review
84
Based on 2 reviews
81
Sleeping Cool
Based on 8 reviews
80
Based on 10 reviews
81
Comfort
Based on 7 reviews
83
Based on 6 reviews
77
What the experts are saying
Katie Golde
Katie Golde
Mattress Clarity
"thoughtfully designed a memory foam mattress that contours to your body to allow you..."
Joe Auer
Joe Auer
Mattress Clarity
"Definitely a solid mattress with no frills, and a very reputable company providing a..."
Features
  • Adjusts with box spring, adjustable, slatted, and platform foundations
  • Quilted memory foam for enhanced comfort
  • Available in different sizes from Twin to Cal King
  • Excellent pressure relief
  • Suitable for all sleeping positions
  • Suits all foundations (slat base, platform base, adjustable bed, box-spring)
  • Pressure relief through exceptional conforming
  • Medium-firm firmness level
  • Cool and breathable feel
  • Serves all sleeping positions (side sleeper, back sleeper, stomach sleeper)

Brand Comparison

Nectar Brand Logo Tuft and Needle Brand Logo
2016 Year of Origin 2012
San Francisco Headquarters Location Phoenix, Arizona
365 Sleep Trial Period (days) 100
25 Warranty (years) 10
Yes Free Delivery Yes
No International Shipping No

Tuft and Needle started way before Nectar. It is among the first, most affordable bed-in-a-box brands that completely disrupted the otherwise store-centered mattress industry. JT Marino and Daehee Park set-up Tuft and Needle company with an aim to produce an excellent mattress sold at a low cost to all.

Nectar, on the other hand, was founded a couple of years back by Craig Schmeizer. This brand introduced the bed-in-a-box industry to a relatively new mattress technology, known as gel memory foam. Again, the affordability of their product instantly caught the attention of a vast clientele, paving a path for their success.

Even though it is apparent that Tuft and Needle brand has been in the industry far longer than Nectar, both companies are still equally popular among Americans.

Trial Period

Perhaps the most striking difference is the trial period offered by each brand. While Tuft and Needle mattress has a 100 nights trial policy, Nectar mattress buyers can enjoy one whole year of testing at the comfort of their home.

You might wonder if trial period actually matters when you're choosing a mattress. It does if you are thinking of buying a sleep surface that allows a comfy snooze all year long, in every type of season and weather. During the one-year trial, you can check if the Nectar bed suits the varying sleep needs in different climates or not.

With Tuft and Needle, you get to try it for three months, which pretty much limits your testing to just one season. Thus, if you buy it during summer, you wouldn't be able to guess whether or not the mattress is still comfortable during winters.

Warranty

Just like most of the brands, Tuft and Needle warranty lasts for 10 years. However, Nectar offers a ‘Forever Warranty' promise, which is a fancy phrase for a 25-years warranty.

Per the Nectar warranty , you can get a new bed for half the price without returning the old Nectar. Tuft and Needle, however, donate your old mattress to a charity organization.

However, it's important to note that claiming a warranty on your mattress after 10 years is a bit difficult. Hence, according to industry experts, basing your choice of mattress solely on an extended warranty period is not recommended.

Delivery/Shipping

All US-based residents can avail free shipping by both brands. Nectar offers mattress delivery to Alaska and Hawaii for a small surcharge, whereas Tuft and Needle only delivers to the contiguous US states. Per the Tuft and Needle and Nectar return policy, the companies ensure a hassle-free return and refund process.

Nectar Mattress
Tuft & Needle Mattress

Mattress Comparison Overview

Both Nectar and Tuft and Needle mattresses are among the top choices of a large number of consumers and industry experts. But while purchasing, a lot of their fundamental similarities and differences are overlooked. Because of this, you may end up buying the ‘wrong' mattress.

Here is an overview of the prominent features and specifications that are similar or different in each model. This information will further help you with the mattress selection process.

  • Similarities
  • Sizes:
    Both mattresses are offered in the same sizes
  • Comfort level:
    They are both medium-firm mattresses
  • Delivery:
    Each of them is sold bed-in-a-box style, free of cost to US residents
  • Affordability:
    These beds lie in the affordable range of mattresses
  • Category:
    Both sleep surfaces are in essence made of foam
  • Differences
  • Construction:
    Tuft and Needle construction is pretty straightforward whereas Nectar comes with frills.
  • Height:
    Tuft and Needle has a thin profile; Nectar has a thick height.
  • Cooling technology:
    Nectar uses a gel memory foam whereas Tuft and Needle has a graphite and gel infusion for cooling.
  • Longevity:
    Tuft and Needle has lower average durability than Nectar.
  • Manufacturing country:
    Nectar is made in China while Tuft and Needle is manufactured in the USA.

Mattress Comparison Details

Here is an in-depth comparison of both models explaining the numerous differences in their features and quality:

1. Materials and Construction

Although both beds are essentially made of foam, when you compare Nectar to Tuft and Needle, you can see a significant difference in construction, materials, and structures.

Nactar:

Nectar consists of four foam layers, forming a structure 11 inches in height.

  • 1-inch Gel Memory foam, ensuring exceptional contouring of your body curves.
  • 0.5-inch support layer called Adaptive Hi-Core Memory foam, featuring a balance of bounciness and cushioning.
  • The 6 inches thick Nectar mattress foundation improves the overall longevity.
Nectar Mattress Layers

Tuft and Needle:

This mattress has a 10 inches thick profile comprising two layers of foam.

  • 3-inches thick Adaptive comfort foam with an infusion of graphite and gel, providing adequate responsiveness to the mattress.
  • The Support base layer, 7 inches in height, working as a strong foundation.
Tuft and Needle Mattress Layers
Key Differences
Height Tuft and Needle mattress is 10 inches thick while Nectar is 11 inches.
Number of Layers Tuft and Needle mattress comprises two layers while Nectar has four.
Cover Nectar is enclosed in a Tencel cover while Tuft and Needle mattress has a soft micro polyamide and polyester cover.
Comfort Layer Nectar comfort layer is thinner than Tuft and Needle.
Comfort Layer Material Tuft and Needle uses graphite wicking material in the comfort layer. Nectar has a gel comfort foam.
Support Layer Nectar mattress has a separate support layer while Tuft and Needle only has a combined base and support layer.
Support Layer Material While Nectar focuses on gel memory foam, Tuft and Needle mattress has a pure polyfoam support surface.

2. Firmness

Firmness or the comfort level of a mattress plays a vital role in the overall feel of the bed. Apparently, both these beds have a medium-firm comfort level.

However, the firmness comparison of Tuft and Needle vs. Nectar mattress shows that Nectar is slightly firmer in feel than Tuft and Needle, due to the presence of gel memory foam. The gel beads tend to make the surface of memory foam a little firm, resulting in less sinkage that you usually experience on memory foam beds.

Therefore, when you compare Nectar to Tuft and Needle mattress you will notice the surface contouring your curves but limited sink-in feel. Whereas, on the latter, the sleepers experience a cushioning feel due to the slightly less firm foam.

Key Differences
Nectar
Medium 5/10
  • Extra Soft
  • Soft
  • Medium
  • Plush Firm
  • Firm
Tuft and Needle
Medium firm 7/10
  • Extra Soft
  • Soft
  • Medium
  • Plush Firm
  • Firm
Firmness Tuft and Needle is slightly softer in feel than Nectar.

3. Support

Both mattresses excel in terms of offering support. Foam is popular among consumers who have joint ache or back pain problems due to the superb contouring capabilities. However, even though these mattresses are foam, Tuft and Needle support is a bit different from Nectar.

The support layer of Tuft and Needle provides incredible cushioning support to your pressure points and adjusts to your body weight by adequately distributing it along the mattress surface. Hence, consumers who are prone to joints pain or bone inflammation such as arthritis, feel enhanced support on Tuft and Needle.

Per Nectar mattress customer reviews, it is preferred mostly by people who have back pain issues. The quilted gel foam cradles the lower back and hips, gently cushioning it all night long. The slightly firmer construction further promotes exceptional spinal alignment, one of the major concerns for people who have back issues.

Key Differences
Nectar Best for back pain relief.
Tuft and Needle Offers excellent cushioning of joints.

4. Temperature Regulation

Temperature regulation is yet another integral feature you must consider in both mattresses. If you are prone to sweating at night, you might want to opt for a mattress which has a proper heat distribution technology.

You'll find both mattress brands claiming their product has a unique temperature regulating property. But which one is better?

Tuft and Needle has a heat wicking graphite and gel infusion in the comfort layer, which primarily draws heat away from the body. In addition, the micro polyamide and polyester cover promotes air circulation.

On the other hand, Nectar has two layers of gel memory foam, consisting of cooling gel beads for decreasing hot sleep issues. Besides, the entire mattress is enclosed in a Tencel cooling cover, made of moisture and heat wicking fabric. The Tencel cover is known for its softness and increased breathability.

The analysis of Tuft and Needle customer reviews shows that people who sleep on this mattress may experience hot sleep. Hence, for proper heat distribution feature, try Nectar.

Key Differences
Nectar Gel memory foam layers + Tencel cooling cover.
Tuft and Needle Graphite and gel infusion + micro polyamide and polyester cover.

5. Motion Transfer

A mattress with motion isolation feature prevents motion transfer due to movements. Couples or pet owners look for this property so they can enjoy an uninterrupted night's rest.

Both Tuft and Needle and Nectar utilize foam, a material that limits motion transfer. However, Nectar is known to have better motion isolation than Tuft and Needle mainly because of the high-density foam, as it prevents transference of movements when your partner or pet moves.

Thus, when light sleepers or couples compare Tuft and Needle to Nectar, they prefer the gel infused, firmer Nectar, so they can sleep without any disturbances.

Key Differences
Motion Isolation Nectar has better motion isolation than Tuft and Needle

6. Body Type Suitability

Your body type plays an integral part during mattress selection. Many beds suit the regular body type, and there is a lack of models that adjust to either light or heavyweight individuals.

Nectar has a dense support layer which serves as a sturdy lower foam, keeping the layers above intact for a long time. Thus, people who are more on the heavyweight side (weighing more than 180 lbs) may opt for this mattress.

Tuft and Needle uses less durable materials than Nectar, which is why it is unable to hold up for years if a heavyweight individual uses this mattress regularly. Tuft and Needle bed is suitable for individuals who have an average or light body weight.

Key Differences
Lightweight (<149 lbs) Average Weight
(150 lbs - 179 lbs)
Heavyweight
(>180 lbs)
Nectar Not Suitable Suitable Suitable
Tuft and Needle Suitable Suitable Not Suitable

7. Sleep Positions Adjustability

Both Tuft and Needle and Nectar use unique types of foams due to which each of them suits a different sleep position.

As Tuft and Needle bed has a soft comfort level than Nectar, it adjusts well to side sleepers and back sleepers. The mattress offers exceptional contouring of body curves such as shoulders and hips, the main pressure points, making it ideal for both positions.

Stomach sleepers may experience breathability or temperature regulation issues, while combination sleepers feel stuck in the bed. Hence, Tuft and Needle may not be an optimal choice for people who sleep in either of these positions.

Nectar properly adjusts to combination sleepers, back sleepers, and stomach sleepers. The slightly firmer construction, combined with the cushioning support of quilted comfort foam, allows contouring of main pressure points, including the lower back. Thus, you experience excellent back pain relief and spinal alignment.

Side sleepers may feel increased pressure due to Nectar firmness on shoulders and hips. Stomach sleepers don't feel heat or breathability issues, thanks to Tencel cover. Besides, the mattress keeps their back straight while lying on the front.

Combination sleepers can easily change their sleep position during the night without disturbance on Nectar due to gel foam resilience.

Key Differences
Side
Sleepers
Back
Sleepers
Stomach
Sleepers
Combination
Sleepers
Nectar Not Suitable Suitable Suitable Suitable
Tuft and Needle Suitable Suitable Not Suitable Not Suitable

8. Price and Overall Value

In terms of price, Tuft and Needle cost is less than Nectar. Hence, people who are looking for budget-friendly choices prefer Tuft and Needle mattress.

On the other hand, when it comes to overall value, Nectar performs better over the years than Tuft and Needle. The latter loses its structure and shape after regular use while Nectar lasts longer and is more durable. Nectar's durability is owed to the high-quality and dense materials used in the mattress which makes it resistant to premature sagging.

Key Differences
Price Tuft and Needle is less expensive than Nectar.
Value Nectar has better value than Tuft and Needle.
Nectar Brand Logo Tuft & Needle Brand Logo

Size and Pricing

Brand Logo Nectar Brand Logo Tuft & Needle
$524 Twin: 39" x 75" $350
$594 Twin XL: 39" x 80" $395
$724 Full: 54" x 75" $495
$824 Queen: 60" x 80" $595
$1024 King: 76" x 80" $750
$1024 Cali King: 72" x 84" $750

all prices are the latest official prices we found on the manufacturer's website
to check for special offer click here

The Bottom Line

As you can gather from the detailed Tuft and Needle vs. Nectar analysis above, it is difficult to pin either of these mattresses as the ultimate best. Both have specific advantages and disadvantages – the selection mainly depends on your mattress preferences.