Disclaimer: Every time you use one of our affiliate links, we earn a commission. Your purchase supports our research so we can bring you the best info about sleep products. Learn More

Casper Essential, Nectar, and Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea: A Side-by-Side Comparison from SleePare

Wondering what's really the big difference between all of the different online-exclusive mattress brands that have popped up in recent years? At SleePare, we've done the research for you and have created a comprehensive online comparison of all of today's top mattress brands to take the guesswork out of shopping for an online mattress. Here's how three of the top online-only bed-in-a-box mattresses stack up against each other.

At-a-Glance: Casper Essential, Nectar, and Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea

Casper Essential, Nectar and Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea are all multi-layer memory foam mattresses that work well on adjustable bed bases. Each brand boasts quick, hassle-free delivery; the mattress are delivered rolled in boxes and are easy to unpack.

Casper Essential Logo

Casper Essential

Pro Score
82
User Score
77

An all-foam mattress at an affordable low price.

Nectar logo

Nectar

Pro Score
94
User Score
94

A four-layer, gel-infused memory foam mattress with a 365 day trial.

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo

Zinus Pressure Relief

Pro Score
85
User Score
84

A green-tea infused memory foam mattress with cooling technology.

Casper Essential Logo
Casper Essential
Nectar logo
Nectar
Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo
Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea

Side-by-Side Comparison

The comparisons below are based on the information available for each brand's Queen-sized mattress.

Casper Essential Logo

Price (Queen)

$595

Nectar logo

Price (Queen)

$799

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo

Price (Queen)

$344

Casper Essential Logo

Weight

63 lbs

Nectar logo

Weight

74 lbs

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo

Weight

59 lbs

Casper Essential Logo

Height

11 inches

Nectar logo

Height

11 inches

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo

Height

12 inches

Casper Essential Logo

Components

3 layers foam

Nectar logo

Components

4 layers foam

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo

Components

4 layers foam

Casper Essential Logo

Warranty

10 years

Nectar logo

Warranty

Forever

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo

Warranty

10 years

Casper Essential Logo

Feel

Medium Firm

Nectar logo

Feel

Medium

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo

Feel

Medium

Casper Essential Logo

Other sizes available

Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Nectar logo

Other sizes available

Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo

Other sizes available

Twin, Full, Full XL, Queen, King, California King

Expert Reviews

Value for money

Casper Essential Logo
73

Based on 4 reviews

Nectar logo
85

Based on 9 reviews

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo
100

Based on 5 reviews

Owner Satisfaction

Casper Essential Logo
69

Based on 2 reviews

Nectar logo
84

Based on 1 reviews

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo
67

Based on 1 reviews

Sleeping Cool

Casper Essential Logo
71

Based on 3 reviews

Nectar logo
80

Based on 8 reviews

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo
66

Based on 3 reviews

Comfort

Casper Essential Logo
69

Based on 2 reviews

Nectar logo
83

Based on 7 reviews

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo
87

Based on 2 reviews

What the experts are saying

Casper Essential Logo

Nick Robinson

Sleep Like The Dead

"Casper mattresses appear to have at least somewhat better durability / longevity than..."

Nectar logo

Katie Golde

Mattress Clarity

"thoughtfully designed a memory foam mattress that contours to your body to allow you..."

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea logo

Joe Auer

Mattress Clarity

"good sleeping experience on the mattress, and I think one of the Zinus options could..."

Summary

Nectar

Value

"All three mattress are extremely budget-friendly, each boasting a price tag well below the $1,000 mark. Zinus’ Pressure Relief Green Tea mattress is the least expensive of the bunch, at just under $350 for its 12-inch thick Queen model, though some customer reviews indicate that there may be some concerns as to how much life they may be able to get out of the Zinus. The Casper Essential is middle-of-the-road in terms of price, though they also benefit from high brand name recognition. The gel-infused Nectar is the priciest of the bunch, but the mattress comes with the Nectar “Forever” warranty, which protects the mattress for as long as you own it."

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea

Comfort

"A comfortable mattress is key to healthy sleep. Casper Essential, Nectar and Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea are all comfortable memory foam surfaces, so for consumers the choice will come down largely to sleeping position and comfort level preference. For a softer, more plush feel, try the Zinus; if you prefer a firmer mattress, you may want to check out the Casper Essential or Nectar."

Nectar

Support

"Nectar and Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea are suitable mattresses for all body types. Their multi-layer construction is designed to support weights above 200 pounds, with the Nectar mattress guaranteeing support for up to 500 pounds. Nectar’s gel-infused foam also gives it more points for comfort over the Zinus model, as the gel promotes cooling in a way that memory foam typically does not. With one less layer of foam than the Nectar or Zinus mattresses, the Casper Essential is perhaps better for lighter weights, though the memory foam construction means it’ll contour easily to the shape of the body and relieve pressure points."

Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea

Motion transfer

"For couples and pet owners, memory foam mattresses tend to be preferable due to their ability to isolate movement and reduce motion transfer. However, not all mattresses are created equal; the Casper Essential is slightly bouncier than Nectar or Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea, so it may transfer motion more easily if one or both partners move a lot at night. Both Nectar and Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea are reported to have superior motion isolation properties due to their multi-layer foam and gel construction."

The Bottom Line

While the Casper Essential has great brand recognition and the Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea is offered at a nearly unbeatable price point. the Nectar mattress is by and large the favorite of both consumers and experts thanks to its cooling gel technology and quilted memory foam construction. Though more expensive than either the Casper Essential or the Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea mattresses, Nectar’s mattress is nonetheless at an excellent, budget-friendly price point, all while offering exceptional support and comfort. Of course, preferences vary from person to person, so it’s always wise to take advantage of any trial periods offered – or even better, to test the mattress in-store before making a purchase.

Want a free, in-person trial of Casper Essential, Nectar, or Zinus Pressure Relief Green Tea? You can find all three exclusively at SleePare – book an appointment today!