The Bottom LineAveline is a basic economy class mattress, suitable for students on a very tight budget. Lucid offers more variety of comfort levels and mattress thickness in its memory foam collection. However, Nest Bedding Love and Sleep is quite affordable and provides a much higher cost-based value, quality, and durability. The US-made Love and Sleep comes with a lifetime warranty, and customer service is remarkable too. Being thicker than both Aveline and Lucid, Love and Sleep supports all body structures and is available in Medium and Firm comforts, suitable for majority sleepers. It is also a better choice for couples. Aveline is a bit bouncier and flexible, might work for those seeking inexpensive, temporary sleep solution. The China-made Lucid is available in either Soft or Firm and no firmness in between. All three mattresses are very affordable, but Nest Bedding Love and Sleep is clearly our choice here, for a reliable, budget-friendly, and an extremely comfortable high-value purchase.