Disclaimer: Every time you use one of our affiliate links, we earn a commission. Your purchase supports our research so we can bring you the best info about sleep products. Learn More

<

Amerisleep AS5 vs Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top vs Tuft and Needle

Amerisleep AS5, Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top and Tuft and Needle are included in the same product category. During periodic maintenance, you can easily reverse these beds. These models fit adjustable bed bases perfectly. The delivery is quick and hassle-free.

Amerisleep AS5 Logo

Amerisleep AS5

Pro Score
89
User Score
87

AmeriSleep As5 is the softest, thickest and most...

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top

Pro Score
89
User Score
96

The Kirkville Super Pillow Top is a cool, comfortable...

Tuft and Needle logo

Tuft and Needle

Pro Score
89
User Score
88

The Tuft & Needle is a renowned mattress with two foam...

Amerisleep AS5 Logo
Amerisleep AS5
Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo
Amerisleep AS5
Tuft and Needle logo
Tuft and Needle

Details

Amerisleep AS5 Logo

Price (Queen)

2100

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo

Price (Queen)

900

Tuft and Needle logo

Price (Queen)

595

Amerisleep AS5 Logo

Sizes

Cali King, Full, King, Queen, Split King, Twin, Twin XL

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo

Sizes

Cali King, Full, King, Queen, Twin, Twin XL

Tuft and Needle logo

Sizes

Cali King, Full, King, Queen, Twin, Twin XL

Amerisleep AS5 Logo

Weight (Queen)

104

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo

Weight (Queen)

57

Tuft and Needle logo

Weight (Queen)

70

Amerisleep AS5 Logo

Mattress Build

4 layers foam

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo

Mattress Build

3 layers foam and springs

Tuft and Needle logo

Mattress Build

2 layers foam

Amerisleep AS5 Logo

Quilted Foam

No

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo

Quilted Foam

Yes

Tuft and Needle logo

Quilted Foam

No

Amerisleep AS5 Logo

Warranty

20 Years

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo

Warranty

10 Years

Tuft and Needle logo

Warranty

10 Years10

Amerisleep AS5 Logo

Trial Period

100

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo

Trial Period

45

Tuft and Needle logo

Trial Period

100

Amerisleep AS5 Logo

Bed in a box

Yes

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo

Bed in a box

No

Tuft and Needle logo

Bed in a box

Yes

Amerisleep AS5 Logo

Height

14

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo

Height

14

Tuft and Needle logo

Height

10

Amerisleep AS5 Logo

Comfort Level offered

Soft

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo

Comfort Level offered

Medium soft

Tuft and Needle logo

Comfort Level offered

Medium firm

Customer Reviews

Comfortable Rating

Amerisleep AS5 Logo
95

Based on 11 reviews

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo
95

Based on 12 reviews

Tuft and Needle logo
92

Based on 488 reviews

Support

Amerisleep AS5 Logo
88

Based on 5 reviews

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo
88

Based on 4 reviews

Tuft and Needle logo
95

Based on 610 reviews

Most Positive Review

Amerisleep AS5 Logo

"The aches and pains that I woke up each morning with getting older. "

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo

"Enjoy our new bed and box spring I sleep all night now don't wake up with sore hips or shoulders excellent bed.."

Tuft and Needle logo

"I have an immune disease that makes my joints hurt all night. With Tuft and Needle, my joints are fine. I slept. It is good. "

Expert Reviews

Value for money

Amerisleep AS5 Logo
88

Based on 1 reviews

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo
71

Based on 1 reviews

Tuft and Needle logo
78

Based on 11 reviews

Owner Satisfaction

Amerisleep AS5 Logo
86

Based on 1 reviews

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo
72

Based on 1 reviews

Tuft and Needle logo
81

Based on 2 reviews

What the experts are saying

Amerisleep AS5 Logo

Mark Reddick

Sleep Advisor

“Amerisleep line is not the cheapest on the market, but its still one of the best value...”

Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo

Chris Moberg

Slumber Search

“Their mid-grade Cushion Top Firm Pillow Top runs medium firm, has a top layer of gel...”

Tuft and Needle logo

Joe Auer

Mattress Clarity

“If someone is looking for an all-foam mattress at a value price, the Tuft and Needle...”

Features

Amerisleep AS5 Logo
  • Works well with wooden slats, solid surface and spring base
  • Great pressure-relief
  • Limited sink-in feel
  • Excellent value-based product
  • Eco-friendly materials with no off-gassing
Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo
  • Well-suited to the Serta adjustable foundations
  • Quilt top layer for extra comfort and coolness
  • Minimal motion transfer
  • Available in various sizes (from Twin to Cali King)
  • Targeted pressure relief
Tuft and Needle logo
  • Suits all foundations (slat base, platform base, adjustable bed, box-spring)
  • Pressure relief through exceptional conforming
  • Medium-firm firmness level
  • Cool and breathable feel
  • Serves all sleeping positions (side sleeper, back sleeper, stomach sleeper)
Amerisleep AS5 Logo
Amerisleep AS5
Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top logo
Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top
Tuft and Needle logo
Tuft and Needle

Summary

Amerisleep AS5

Comfort

"A comfortable mattress ensures a deep sleep. Amerisleep AS5, Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top and Tuft and Needle all are comfortable sleep surfaces. However, the choice depends on your sleeping position and comfort level preferences. For a plush feel, Amerisleep AS5 is an excellent choice while for a firmer feel, you may want to check out Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top or Tuft and Needle. "

Tuft and Needle

Support

"Tuft and Needle and Amerisleep AS5 are more adaptable to people with heavyweight than the skinny people. The heavy layered structure is built to support people weighing over 200lbs. Lightweight people might like Serta Perfect Sleeper Kirkville Super Pillow Top better as its plush structure fits perfectly to the body curves and provides adequate pain relief to pressure points."

The Bottom Line

Conclusively, Amerisleep AS5 is a great mattress offering exceptional comfort at a low price. Whereas when it comes to support Tuft and Needle is a viable option. Depending on your sleeping habits and preferences, all three mattresses are designed to rejuvenate your mornings through relaxing nights.

Call Us
Book appointment