Disclaimer: Every time you use one of our affiliate links, we earn a commission. Your purchase supports our research so we can bring you the best info about sleep products. Learn More

<

Amerisleep AS4 vs Puffy vs Casper vs Tuft and Needle

Amerisleep AS4, Puffy, Casper and Tuft and Needle all belong to the same product category. Their design elements allow the mattresses to adjust to the changing base. The quilted foam is breathable, maintaining a hygienic sleep surface. The shipping is quick and hassle-free. It takes only a few days to receive your products. The brands keep you informed of each step of your order. The compressed package is easy to handle. Moreover, unboxing is effortless. Mattress decompression is almost instant.

Amerisleep AS4 Logo

Amerisleep AS4

Pro Score
89
User Score
85

The AmeriSleep AS4 is another soft mattress designed...

Puffy logo

Puffy

Pro Score
89
User Score
91

Puffy is a three-layered foam mattress manufactured by...

Casper logo

Casper

Pro Score
89
User Score
85

The Casper Original is a popular foam mattress by...

Tuft and Needle logo

Casper

Pro Score
89
User Score
88

The Tuft & Needle is a renowned mattress with two foam...

Amerisleep AS4 Logo
Amerisleep AS4
Puffy logo
Amerisleep AS4
Casper logo
Casper
Tuft and Needle logo
Tuft and Needle

Details

Amerisleep AS4 Logo

Price (Queen)

1700

Puffy logo

Price (Queen)

1150

Casper logo

Price (Queen)

1095

Tuft and Needle logo

Price (Queen)

595

Amerisleep AS4 Logo

Sizes

Cali King, Full, King, Queen, Split King, Twin, Twin XL

Puffy logo

Sizes

Cali King, Full, King, Queen, Twin, Twin XL

Casper logo

Sizes

Cali King, Full, King, Queen, Twin, Twin XL

Tuft and Needle logo

Sizes

Cali King, Full, King, Queen, Twin, Twin XL

Amerisleep AS4 Logo

Weight (Queen)

94

Puffy logo

Weight (Queen)

69

Casper logo

Weight (Queen)

71

Tuft and Needle logo

Weight (Queen)

70

Amerisleep AS4 Logo

Mattress Build

3 layers foam

Puffy logo

Mattress Build

2 layers foam

Casper logo

Mattress Build

3 layers foam

Tuft and Needle logo

Mattress Build

2 layers foam

Amerisleep AS4 Logo

Reversible

Yes

Puffy logo

Reversible

No

Casper logo

Reversible

Yes

Tuft and Needle logo

Reversible

Yes

Amerisleep AS4 Logo

Warranty

20 Years

Puffy logo

Warranty

Lifetime

Casper logo

Warranty

10 Years10

Tuft and Needle logo

Warranty

10 Years10

Amerisleep AS4 Logo

Trial Period

100

Puffy logo

Trial Period

101

Casper logo

Trial Period

100

Tuft and Needle logo

Trial Period

100

Amerisleep AS4 Logo

Height

12

Puffy logo

Height

10

Casper logo

Height

11

Tuft and Needle logo

Height

10

Amerisleep AS4 Logo

Comfort Level offered

Medium soft

Puffy logo

Comfort Level offered

Medium firm

Casper logo

Comfort Level offered

Medium firm

Tuft and Needle logo

Comfort Level offered

Medium firm

Customer Reviews

Comfortable Rating

Amerisleep AS4 Logo
92

Based on 7 reviews

Puffy logo
100

Based on 69 reviews

Casper logo
95

Based on 429 reviews

Tuft and Needle logo
92

Based on 488 reviews

Support

Amerisleep AS4 Logo
85

Based on 2 reviews

Puffy logo
92

Based on 27 reviews

Casper logo
92

Based on 351 reviews

Tuft and Needle logo
95

Based on 610 reviews

Value for money

Amerisleep AS4 Logo
88

Based on 5 reviews

Puffy logo
88

Based on 15 reviews

Casper logo
92

Based on 273 reviews

Tuft and Needle logo
92

Based on 488 reviews

Temperature Regulation

Amerisleep AS4 Logo
85

Based on 3 reviews

Puffy logo
88

Based on 15 reviews

Casper logo
95

Based on 390 reviews

Tuft and Needle logo
95

Based on 610 reviews

Most Positive Review

Amerisleep AS4 Logo

"My wife hips bothered her tremendously on our old memory foam, not anymore. "

Puffy logo

"When I wake up in the mornings I no longer have hip pain or knee pain."

Casper logo

" I believe it has relieved some of my joint pain."

Tuft and Needle logo

"I have an immune disease that makes my joints hurt all night. With Tuft and Needle, my joints are fine. I slept. It is good. "

Expert Reviews

Value for money

Amerisleep AS4 Logo
92

Based on 3 reviews

Puffy logo
87

Based on 6 reviews

Casper logo
84

Based on 12 reviews

Tuft and Needle logo
78

Based on 11 reviews

Owner Satisfaction

Amerisleep AS4 Logo
86

Based on 1 reviews

Puffy logo
98

Based on 1 reviews

Casper logo
82

Based on 2 reviews

Tuft and Needle logo
81

Based on 2 reviews

Sleeping Cool

Amerisleep AS4 Logo
80

Based on 1 reviews

Puffy logo
92

Based on 6 reviews

Casper logo
85

Based on 11 reviews

Tuft and Needle logo
81

Based on 10 reviews

Comfort

Amerisleep AS4 Logo
95

Based on 2 reviews

Puffy logo
90

Based on 5 reviews

Casper logo
87

Based on 8 reviews

Tuft and Needle logo
77

Based on 6 reviews

What the experts are saying

Amerisleep AS4 Logo

Joe Auer

Mattress Clarity

“high quality memory foam mattress, Amerisleep performs exceedingly well. ...”

Puffy logo

Chris Young

Get Best Mattress

“ an excellent mattress that comes with Cooling Cloud and Firm Core Support...”

Casper logo

Joe Auer

Mattress Clarity

“The heart and soul of the Casper mattress is its Zoned Support system this is a layer...”

Tuft and Needle logo

Joe Auer

Mattress Clarity

“If someone is looking for an all-foam mattress at a value price, the Tuft and Needle...”

Features

Amerisleep AS4 Logo
  • Designed especially for side sleepers
  • Medium-soft comfort level
  • Proper contouring for pressure relief
  • Eco-friendly materials
  • Comes in different sizes ranging from Twin to Cali King
Puffy logo
  • Adjusts to all bed foundations/frames (slat, platform, adjustable bed, box springs)
  • Pressure relieving surface
  • Super cool and temperature regulating
  • Medium firm comfort level
  • Perfect for back and side sleepers
Casper logo
  • Works with wooden slats, platform, adjustable bed base
  • Bouncy comfort layer providing resilience
  • Budget-friendly price
  • Cool and breathable feel
  • Great edge support
Tuft and Needle logo
  • Suits all foundations (slat base, platform base, adjustable bed, box-spring)
  • Pressure relief through exceptional conforming
  • Medium-firm firmness level
  • Cool and breathable feel
  • Serves all sleeping positions (side sleeper, back sleeper, stomach sleeper)
Amerisleep AS4 Logo
Amerisleep AS4
Puffy logo
Puffy
Casper logo
Casper
Tuft and Needle logo
Tuft and Needle

Summary

Tuft and Needle

Cost based value

"Casper matches Puffy and Amerisleep AS4 closely in terms of cost-based value. Tuft and Needle has the best quality for price with a strong and sturdy structure and exceptionally comfortable and supportive sleep surface."

Casper

Comfort

"Casper has the softest sleep surface in comparison to Tuft and Needle, Amerisleep AS4 and Puffy. The use of high-quality plush layers offer contouring support to your body for a comfy rest. For a firmer comfort level, consider Casper."

Tuft and Needle

Support

"Tuft and Needle is more resilient and adjusts your weight exceptionally well compared to Puffy, Casper and Amerisleep AS4. The flexible material used in its construction distribute your weight evenly for a refreshing slumber in all sleeping positions."

Tuft and Needle

Temperature regulation

"Tuft and Needle is better at temperature regulation compared to Casper, Puffy, and Amerisleep AS4. A unique cooling system in Tuft and Needle improves airflow and heat ventilation, keeping sleep surface at an optimal temperature at all times."

The Bottom Line

In short, Tuft and Needle is an excellent choice regarding support, Cost based value and temperature regulation . provide and Casper has an exceptional comfort. All these products are outstanding in performance and cost-based value. Match their individual properties to your preferences and enjoy the best night’s sleep ever!

Call Us
Book appointment