10 Best Custom Mattresses

by SleePare -
10 Best Custom Mattresses

A research conducted by the Better Sleep Council suggests a person’s sleep position might be linked to their health, age, and perhaps even education level.

However, this is only the tip of the iceberg. We’re unique in many other ways, and our differences are reflected in our sleep preferences. Our definitions of comfort and support are relative, so can there really be one mattress to rule them all absolutely?

Fortunately, many manufacturers give you the chance to build your own mattress based on your unique needs and preferences. A custom mattress made just for you practically guarantees you don’t wake up on the wrong side of the bed.

This article will aim to answer all your custom mattress queries. We’ll start off by discussing the need for customizable mattresses before venturing forth into what exactly you cair an alter in a mattress to make it truly unique. Finally, we’ll share some of our picks with you.

Why You Need a Custom Mattress

  • Firmness

    People come in all shapes and sizes, and as much as it would simplify things, there��s no single universal mattress for everyone. Based on your body type, your comfort preferences will vary drastically.

    A thicker, firmer, and more supportive mattress will be a better pick for heavier individuals (above 200 lbs). It will provide them the support they need and prevent them from sinking into the bed.

    Similarly, lighter people will be better off with a thinner and softer mattress. Such a mattress will better conform to their bodies and better cushion pressure points.

  • Different Sleeping Positions

    Sleeping positions also vary across individuals. Some people may prefer sleeping on their backs, stomachs, or sides while others might be combination sleepers or have changing preferences.

    Back sleepers will typically prefer a mattress that cushions better as they are more likely to develop lower back pain. They’ll be more inclined towards memory foam mattresses with soft to medium firmness.

    Side sleepers are more likely to develop pressure points in the hips, neck, and shoulders. For effective pressure alleviation, they’ll need a mattress that conforms nicely to their body.

    Lastly, stomach sleepers are vulnerable to a whole host of spine and back problems. They need a mattress that keeps their spinal alignment in check. A firm mattress with good support would be best for them.

  • Injuries and Medical Conditions

    Mattress preferences can also vary due to any injuries or other medical conditions. This includes both permanent as well as temporary conditions.

    Mattress manufacturers use different synthetic and natural materials in their products, but allergies might limit your choice of materials. In such cases, a mattress that offers alternative materials without compromising on your comfort can be a godsend.

    Similarly, injuries can also give rise to unique comfort preferences, while specific mattress customizations can even facilitate healing. As an example, a person suffering from chronic back pain issues can benefit from a mattress with targeted lumbar support.

    People who suffer from sleep apnea or one with snoring issues should go with a bed with customizable head and foot positions.

  • Sharing a Bed

    If you sleep with a partner with different sleep preferences, a standard mattress just might not cut it. There’s such a huge potential for disagreement. One of you might desire a firmer feeling bed or may sleep hotter than the other.

    A custom mattress can really help you out with this conundrum. With all the choices out there, you can truly create a mattress that takes both partners’ needs into account to ensure everyone is satisfied.

    Even if you and your partner have really divergent support and comfort requirements, you can literally split the mattress in two and have each side customized independently of the other.

  • Non-standard Beds

    Not everyone is looking for a standard mattress for use at home. If you have a bed with a unique shape and size, you’d be all out of options if it weren’t for custom mattresses.

    All a custom mattress maker really needs from you are the dimensions of your bed foundation, and they can tailor make a mattress for almost anything you like.

    Besides the dimensions, you can even choose from different layers and materials to craft the best mattress for your use case. So whether you’re looking for a mattress for your RV, trailer, or even yacht, you can’t go wrong with customization.

  • Dynamic Preferences

    It’s very likely that most things about you, from your weight and sleeping position to your general health and sleeping arrangement, are going to be different in a few years. As a result, your preferences are also subject to change.

    Therefore, it’s just not enough to have a custom mattress that adapts to you. You need a mattress that also adapts to the changes in your life.

    The idea is not very far fetched either since many mattress manufacturers let you adjust your mattress’ configuration for a certain period. In some cases, you can even adjust elements like firmness and thickness yourself from the comfort of your home.

What Can You Customize in a Mattress

  • Size

    This one might seem a bit obvious but bear with us. You might be familiar with standard mattress size options since almost all manufacturers offer them. These include Twin (39 X 75), Twin XL (39 X 80), Full (54 X 75), Queen (60 X 80), King (76 X 80) and California King (72 X 84).

    However, if you’re looking for something to go with your antique bed, boat, truck, or trailer, these might not be enough.

    Fortunately, some manufacturers are not constrained by these conventions, and you can easily have them craft a mattress of custom width and length. This ensures the right fit regardless of your circumstances.

  • Height/Thickness

    Custom thickness deserves a separate mention because it relates to the support and comfort offered by your mattress in some instances. While a thick mattress can be an eyesore sometimes, it can have its benefits depending upon the use case.

    If a mattress isn’t the right thickness, you might sink in so much that you start feeling your bed’s foundational layer. The mattress won’t be able to provide sufficient cushioning, pressure relief, and contouring. This can be a deal breaker, especially for heavier individuals.

    A mattress with thicker foam layers is also generally a better choice for couples as not only can it sustain more weight but also offer better motion isolation. Moreover, a thicker mattress will also be a better choice if you’re going to be placing it on the floor.

  • Firmness

    Firmness or comfort levels aren’t always just a personal preference. They have a lot to do with how much support, pressure relief, and contouring, your mattress can provide and largely depend on your body type and sleeping habits.

    As a rule of thumb, firmer mattresses are more suitable for heavier people and those who like sleeping on their backs and stomachs as they offer better support. Leaner individuals and side sleepers will be better off with a softer mattress for adequate pressure relief.

    To cater to your unique firmness requirements, some manufacturers offer a whole range of options. In some cases, you can even easily change your mattress’ firmness, which can be useful if you’re uncertain about your preferences or have frequently changing ones.

  • Temperature regulation

    All bodies radiate heat, some more than others. Similarly, different mattresses also absorb or dissipate heat to varying degrees. These factors, coupled with your ambient temperature, result in how hot or cold you actually sleep.

    Effective temperature regulation mechanisms typically rely on the choice and structure of materials. However, certain manufacturers allow you to control and customize the temperatures of your sleeping surface actively.

  • Material

    While it’s rare, sometimes manufacturers will also allow you to choose the materials that go into making your mattress. Various characteristics of your mattress are primarily due to the type and quality of materials.

    Certain materials like memory foam contour better according to your body. A person looking for better pressure relief and spinal alignment will prefer memory foam. Similarly, a person looking for better support and responsiveness will go for a hybrid or innerspring mattress.

    Alternatively, your choice might be based on medical reasons (allergies) as well as how or where a particular material is sourced (Made-in-USA).

  • Split Feel

    Most mattress manufacturers provide you the option to choose split firmness and feel preferences if you and your partner are unable to find common ground. This is more common among larger mattress sizes (Queen, King, Cali King) for obvious reasons.

    Besides being split down the middle, mattresses can be further sectioned off into distinct firmness zones for different regions of the body. By providing more support in certain sections of the body while more pressure relief in others, these mattresses can better cater to your individual needs. Such targeted firmness levels are more common in airbeds.

The 10 Highest-rated Custom Mattresses

BrandMattressMattress CategoryTrial PeriodWarranty
Tochta Divini Brand Logo

Tochta Divini

Best feature

Memory foamTrial Period
100 Nights
Warranty
10 years

Read Review

Best feature

Unparalleled customization options

Luxi Brand Logo

Luxi 3-in-1 Adjustable

Best feature

Memory foamTrial Period
100 Nights
Warranty
10 years

Read Review

Best feature

Most customizable memory foam mattress

PlushBeds Brand Logo

PlushBeds Botanical Bliss

Best feature

LatexTrial Period
100 Nights
Warranty
25 years

Read Review

Best feature

Most durable split latex mattress

Helix Sleep Brand Logo

Helix Blended Mattress

Best feature

HybridTrial Period
100 Nights
Warranty
10 years

Read Review

Best feature

Can be customized for side and stomach/back sleepers

Nest Bedding Brand Logo

Nest Bedding Latex Mattress/h3>
Best feature

LatexTrial Period
100 Nights
Warranty
25 years

Read Review

Best feature

Can choose between natural or organic latex

My Morphiis Brand Logo

Morphiis Customizable Mattress

Best feature

FoamTrial Period
100 Nights
Warranty
25 years

Read Review

Best feature

64 firmness configurations out of the box

Sleep Number Brand Logo

Sleep Number 360 p5 Smart Bed

Best feature

AirbedTrial Period
100 Nights
Warranty
25 years

Read Review

Best feature

Dynamic firmness adjustment

Eight Sleep Brand Logo

Eight Sleep Pod

Best feature

FoamTrial Period
100 Nights
Warranty
10 years

Read Review

Best feature

Customizable mattress temperature

Spindle Brand Logo

Spindle Latex Mattress

Best feature

LatexTrial Period
365 Nights
Warranty
20 years

Read Review

Best feature

One Year Comfort Adjustment for free

Sleep EZ Brand Logo

Sleep EZ Select Sleep Organic Latex

Best feature

LatexTrial Period
90 Nights
Warranty
20 years

Read Review

Best feature

Best value split latex mattress

Review of the 10 Best Custom Mattresses

1. Tochta Divini

Tochta Divini Mattress
Customer Satisfaction Ratings for Tochta Divini
Comfort

85

Support

88

Temperature Regulation

82

Durability

75

Overall Value

72

Buy Now
Pros:

Nine firmness levels

Split firmness option

Exchangeable comfort layers (separately sold)

Adjustable thickness (4-10 inches)

Adjustable length (40-90 inches)

Adjustable width (60-80 inches)

Uses only CertiPUR-US® foams

Cons:

Heavier users may experience some sinkage and problems with temperature regulation

Founded in 1980, Tochta has been making completely customizable mattresses for use in homes, RVs, and trucks. All their mattresses are handmade in Southern California.

The Divini is Tochta’s top of the line mattress. It’s a dual zone memory foam mattress that has nine firmness options for each side of the bed.

For ease, you can choose any of the five standard mattress sizes with two thickness options, and play around with firmness settings as well. But if you want, you can go all out with this mattress and delve into some really advanced customization options.

You can choose from multiple length, width, and thickness options to design a totally custom mattress. You can even tweak the size and shape of your mattress’ corners.

Moreover, firmness can be easily customized in the future as well due to its separately sold, swappable comfort layers, and an easy to remove cover. This feature can be useful if you’re unsure about your comfort preferences.

2. Luxi 3-in-1 Adjustable

Luxi 3-in-1 Adjustable Mattress
Customer Satisfaction Ratings for Luxi 3-in-1 Adjustable
Comfort

85

Support

82

Temperature Regulation

72

Durability

78

Overall Value

74

Buy Now
Pros:

Three firmness levels

Split firmness option

Exchangeable foam layers included

Good motion isolation

Cons:

Weak edge support

Not suitable for heavyweight stomach sleepers

Not very responsive

Luxi was founded in 2015 by the father-daughter duo of David and Shannon Farley. They have over 25 years of experience in the foam industry between them.

As the name suggests, you essentially get three mattresses in one with the Luxi Adjustable. By default, the mattress is set to medium firmness, but you can simply make it firmer or softer by unzipping the mattress cover and rearranging the layers.

If you sleep with a partner, Luxi can even hook you up with split layers. You can adjust both sides independently, resulting in nine unique firmness combinations.

Being an all-foam mattress, the Luxi 3-in-1 offers excellent motion isolation but at the expense of responsiveness. Pressure relief is good too, but for adequate support, you’ll need to max out the firmness.

3. PlushBeds Botanical Bliss

PlushBeds Botanical Bliss Mattress
Customer Satisfaction Ratings for PlushBeds Botanical Bliss
Comfort

92

Support

92

Temperature Regulation

85

Durability

85

Overall Value

91

Buy Now
Pros:

Durable construction

Suitable for all sleepers

Two firmness options

Split firmness option

Exchangeable foam layers included

Three height options (9, 10, 12 inches)

Cons:

No plush firmness option available

Heavy and difficult to setup/move

PlushBeds has been manufacturing natural and organic latex mattresses since 2007. They pride themselves on only using eco-friendly and responsibly-sourced materials.

The Botanical Bliss is PlushBeds most customizable mattress and makes use of organic latex layers processed using the Dunlop process. The latex is GOLS and Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certified.

They have two firmness options: Medium for side and combination sleepers and firm for stomach and side sleepers. Firmness can be adjusted from the comfort of your home by unzipping the cover and rearranging the layers of latex.

The Queen, King, and Cali King options have split firmness so you can customize each side independently. The thickness of the mattress can also be adjusted by adding or removing the layers.

4. Helix Blended Mattress

Helix Blended Mattress Mattress
Customer Satisfaction Ratings for Helix Blended Mattress
Comfort

75

Support

72

Temperature Regulation

52

Durability

55

Overall Value

52

Buy Now
Pros:

Three firmness levels

Two support options

Split firmness option

Have options for all types of sleepers

Cons:

Mattress is on the heavier side

Not suitable for people who prefer a pure memory foam or innerspring feel

New York-based Helix Sleep aims to offer a personalized sleeping experience at competitive prices through their high quality, made-to-order mattresses.

Helix mattresses feature a hybrid construction which allows them to provide a good balance of responsiveness and motion isolation. The design also ensures increased air flow to provide a cool feel.

For a truly personalized experience, Helix Sleep takes into consideration a variety of factors. You first fill their sleep quiz specifying your height, weight, and gender, and Helix uses this information to propose the best mattress tailored around your specific sleeping needs.

You can also forego the sleep quiz and choose from different firmness and support options. They offer three firmness options (soft, medium, firm), and two support options (side sleeper, back/stomach sleeper).

Couples with different support and comfort preferences can opt for one of their dual options while there are also options for heavier individuals for maximum support.

5. Nest Bedding Latex Mattress

Nest Bedding Latex Mattress
Customer Satisfaction Ratings for Nest Bedding Latex Mattress
Comfort

85

Support

92

Temperature Regulation

82

Durability

80

Overall Value

83

Buy Now
Pros:

Available in Natural and Organic Latex versions

Three firmness options

Good motion isolation and pressure relief

Cons:

Rubbery feel not for all people

No split firmness option

Soft firmness option requires separately sold mattress topper

Poor edge support

Not suitable for heavy people

Nest Bedding is a family owned and operated company that aims to provide its customers with high-quality US-made sleeping products.

Nest Bedding’s Latex Mattress is the only mattress on this list that lets you choose between certified natural and organic latex. Both types are Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certified and have been produced using the Dunlop process. The organic one also has a GOLS certification.

You have a choice of three firmness options. You can choose between medium or firm while you’re configuring your mattress, but for the soft option, you’ll be required to buy the Nest Bedding Soft Latex Topper as well.

The mattress contours well to your body and offers good motion isolation, but the all-Latex construction has its downsides. The mattress has a rubbery feel and isn’t very responsive. Heavier individuals will also find it lacking in support, especially around the perimeter.

6. Morphiis Customizable Mattress

Morphiis Customizable Mattress
Customer Satisfaction Ratings for Morphiis Customizable Mattress
Comfort

95

Support

88

Temperature Regulation

85

Durability

92

Overall Value

90

Buy Now
Pros:

64 firmness combinations for different user profiles

Suitable for all types of sleepers

Good motion isolation

Cons:

Weak edge support

Initial setup can take some time

Not ideal for people who prefer the feel of an innerspring mattress

Better choices available for heavier individuals

My Morphiis uses their patented ultrafoam in their all-foam customizable mattress. Compared to memory foam, ultrafoam promises to sleep cooler and offer better responsiveness. It mostly succeeds on both counts in our tests.

Out of the box, you get 36 ultrafoam inserts (12 soft, 12 medium, and 12 firm). By mixing and matching these inserts, you can create a variety of firmness configurations.

You can have one firmness level throughout or have split levels on each side. You can even target particular sections of your body by choosing a suitable arrangement. Morphiis has different insert arrangements listed on their website for your convenience.

Since you can configure the mattress according to your needs, all kinds of sleepers are bound to have a good time. It’s still an all-foam mattress, so support isn’t going to be off the charts even if you go for the firmest configuration.

7. Sleep Number 360 p5 Smart Bed

Sleep Number 360 p5 Smart Bed Mattress
Customer Satisfaction Ratings for Sleep Number 360 p5 Smart Bed
Comfort

95

Support

85

Temperature Regulation

85

Durability

85

Overall Value

83

Buy Now
Pros:

Multiple firmness and thickness levels

Split firmness for each side

Different firmness levels for five body zones

Good motion isolation and pressure relief

Automatic and manual controls

Suitable for all sleeper types

SleepIQ integration

Adjustable head and foot position (with adjustable base)

Cons:

Air pumps can be noisy

Expensive

Not responsive enough for sex

Weak edge support and noise suppression

Sleep Number is a pioneer in sleep innovation. It started in 1987 and deals in a variety of beds, bases, and bedding essentials. However, its best known for its range of 360 smart beds.

The 360 p5 is part of Sleep Number’s Performance series. It features an airbed construction with a thick layer of foam on top.

The 24 vulcanized air chambers present in the bed are responsible for the different firmness options. Air pressure in these can be controlled to have different comfort levels for five unique zones of the body on each side of the bed, ensuring a highly personalized experience.

The 360 p5 actively monitors your position throughout and makes adjustments automatically. However, it also pairs easily with your smartphone due to the SleepIQ app. So you can use your phone or the included remote controls to adjust the bed manually.

You can also use the SleepIQ app to track and monitor your breathing, heartbeat, and sleep quality. All of this information is conveniently summarized in your Sleep score.

The bed can also be paired with any one of Sleep Number’s FlexFit bases so you can personalize the bed’s head and foot positions to your liking.

8. Eight Sleep Pod

Eight Sleep Pod Mattress
Customer Satisfaction Ratings for Eight Sleep Pod
Comfort

55

Support

52

Temperature Regulation

52

Durability

55

Overall Value

52

Buy Now
Pros:

Tracks and monitors personal biometrics and sleep activity

Automatic and manual temperature control

Dual zone temperature control

Smart app integration

Suitable for most sleepers

Cons:

Not available in Twin, Twin XL sizes

Only one firmness option available

Not ideal for sex

New York-based, Eight Sleep leverages cutting-edge innovation and personal biometrics to provide consumers with the most rejuvenating sleep possible. Fast Company named it in 2018 as one of the Most Innovative Companies in Consumer Electronics.

The Pod is the only bed on this list that caters to your personal sleeping temperature preferences. It is a smart bed that gathers various biometrics while you sleep to determine the best temperature for your sleep. It then dynamically warms and cools your bed to maintain this temperature.

You can install a companion app on your phone to set your own temperature preferences and to monitor various metrics to gain actionable insights into your sleeping habits. However, our favorite option is the thermal alarm that gradually heats or warms you to wake you up.

The mattress also features Dual-zone temperature control. Temperature is personalized on each side of the bed, ensuring maximum comfort for you and your partner. However, being an all-foam mattress, the Pod lacks responsiveness and isn’t ideal for sex.

9. Spindle Latex Mattress

Spindle Latex Mattress
Customer Satisfaction Ratings for Spindle Latex Mattress
Comfort

95

Support

85

Temperature Regulation

85

Durability

85

Overall Value

91

Buy Now
Pros:

Four firmness levels possible

Good motion isolation and pressure relief

One year comfort adjustment

Online comfort calculator

Cons:

No Cali King option available

No split firmness option

Heavy

Weak edge support

Initial setup can be frustrating

Spindle is a fourth-generation family run mattress manufacturer that takes great pride in providing all-natural, quality mattresses to its customers.

The Spindle Latex mattress ships with three interchangeable natural latex layers. The firmness of each individual layer contributes to the overall firmness of the mattress.

The combination of layers you get will depend on the overall firmness you chose before buying. You’ll still need to arrange these layers yourself when setting up the mattress for the first time.

You can play around with different layer combinations to get the right feel and can even have Spindle swap a layer under their one-year comfort adjustment policy.

Due to the different firmness options, the Spindle mattress does a good job of accommodating all types of sleepers. Spindle even has an online comfort calculator that helps you choose the option with the right firmness and support levels.

10. Sleep EZ Select Sleep Organic Latex Mattress

Sleep EZ Select Sleep Organic Latex Mattress
Customer Satisfaction Ratings for Sleep EZ Select Sleep Organic Latex Mattress
Comfort

92

Support

88

Temperature Regulation

85

Durability

85

Overall Value

85

Buy Now
Pros:

Best value split latex mattress

Choose between Dunlop or Talalay latex

Four thickness options

Suitable for all sleepers

Three interchangeable firmness options

Cons:

Average edge support

Founded in 1976, Sleep EZ is a third generation, family-owned, factory direct mattress manufacturer based in Phoenix, Arizona.

The Select Sleep is a high-quality latex mattress that comes at a very reasonable price. It comprises of three layers of 100% natural latex, which users can easily rearrange or replace at their convenience.

The mattress is highly customizable as you can choose the number of layers as well as the firmness and the type of latex used in each layer (Dunlop or Talalay). You can also pick from 7”, 9″,10″, and 13″ profiles.

The mattress is a good option for couples and can accommodate all kinds of sleepers due to its wide variety of customization options. Overall, it offers the right blend of motion support, pressure relief, and responsiveness.

Comparison and Prices

Mattress NameTwin 39″ x 75″Twin XL 39″ x 80″Full 54″ x 75″Queen 60″ x 80″King 76″ x 80″Cali King 72″ x 84″Buy Now

Tochta Divini

$689N/A$875$999$1250$1250Get Discount

Luxi 3-in-1 Adjustable

$799$849$899$1074$1249$1249Get Discount

PlushBeds Botanical Bliss (3 layers)

$2799$2799$3399$3399$3699$3699Get Discount

Helix Blended Mattress

$600$700$850$995$1245$1245Get Discount

Nest Bedding Latex Mattress

$1199$1299$1499$1699$2099$2099Get Discount

Morphiis Customizable Mattress

$495$550$750$895$1095$1095Get Discount

Sleep Number 360 p5 Smart Bed

$1849$1999$2274$2399$2899$2899Get Discount

Eight Sleep Pod

N/AN/A$1935$2135$2435$2435Get Discount

Spindle Latex Mattress

$1999$1999$2799$3099$3799N/AGet Discount

Sleep EZ Select Sleep Organic Latex Mattress

$1195$1250$1995$2190$2500$2500Get Discount

Compare Mattress

Compare Mattress

Compare

Additional SleePare Resources

Additional SleePare Resources